Semi Auto vs Revolver: The Lost Art Of Pistol Whipping

One Lung Wonder

BANNED
BANNED
BANNED
EE Expired
Rating - 100%
5   0   0
Location
Aaaaaadmontin AB
Once in awhile (it usually happens when I should be working) - an irrelevant and unrelated asynchronous thought will pop into my head with all the abruptness of an echoing popcorn fart in a large empty room: it's not something to lose sleep over but it does demand inordinate amounts of processing power from the higher brain functions... Didjya ever notice that hardly anybody ever gets pistol whipped anymore?

When I was a kid even the vilest of villains could be sent to on a sprawling, painless trip to La La Land with a nice easy clip behind the ear. For Matt Dillon and Festus it was like Captain Kirk putting his phasers on stun - the bad guys hit the ground like a sack of wet cement, and were promptly hog tied and properly hung or incarcerated after a hasty (but fair) trial. The Cartwrights weren't half bad at it either. I think Cullen Bohannon pistol whipped Mr. Durant (he should have shot that no-good sumbi*ch) but other than that - it seems that pistol whipping is no longer part and parcel of pistolcraft! Indiana Jones didn't even crack his whip or raise a fist when confronted by a scimitar wielding skunk - he just shot him with contempt and that was that for that!

I don't think it would surprise anyone to learn that I was pistol whipped on a regular basis. Back in the day our cap guns were as heavy and well made as anything you fellas have in the gun safe: they were all metal, maybe some plastic on the grips - and flashier than anything coming out of Les Baer's skunkworx! When it came time for Cowboys & Indians I was always a villain or an expendable sidekick because I was the youngest and one day I was caught thieving cattle or Billy McEwit's bubble gum - and he brought his cap firing .45 down on my noggin and I got laid out flat! I got 6 stitches out of that and then I got pounded again by the big kids because the incident led to our parents confiscating our guns, bikes and baseball mitts for a week!:redface:

So I'm looking at the guns these days and I am seeing a lot of bumpers on the auto gun magazines...and if you tried to goon a guy with a thick skull like yours Truly with such a weapon, he'd probably spit in your eye instead of folding up. And it seems every second revolver you see these days have the soft Hogue or Pachmyer rubber grips on them.

One is tempted to regard this as a joke (and for all intents and purposes that's the way it's written) - but for the black powder geeks this is serious business. When the swabbies were repelling pirates with their flintlock pistols, or going hand to hand with them on the beach you had one shot - and then your pistol's merit relied on it's handiness as a club! Question: does the modern pistol still have any merit in such a role? I think it might for the single actions and maybe some of the bigger magnums...but other than that...if you are in the soup and fighting your way out, once your pistol runs dry the best course of action, tactically speaking...is to throw it at your assailant!:confused:
 
Ok I'll play! When it comes to pistol whipping, nothing beats a quality revolver. I think the ideal length would be between 4 and six inch barrel. Or 4.2 if you are Canadian. Dirty Harry"s model 29 would do in a pinch but it seems way too long for close quarters pistol whipping.
In the semi auto world the Colt Gov't model seems appropriate. Would have to be an all steel gun, with extra style points for stainless or chrome. (Can you say Pimp Smack?)
I could picture John Wayne dishing out a good pistol whipping with either a revolver or a parkerized 1911, but not a Glock. And he wouldn't drive a Saturn either! ;)
 
If find this tongue in cheek funny.......but, physics being physics says the longer the lever end, the greater the kinetic energy from a swing.
Henceforth a longer barrel could create more impact energy when one reverts your grip and uses it just like a hammer. Eight inches or better, from the heaviest frame, would technically be the winner here.
Lots of points for a Dan Wesson with a long pipe, or a Blackhawk or Redhawk, Anaconda too. Heck, this is the comfort zone for a Walker!

lol
 
This thread can go nowhere unless you consider style: The classic Hollywood whip, or a primitive hammer technique. I think using a long barreled revolver with a downward hammer/axe swing would be best. As an aside, I guess polymer guns would be useless unless it had a full magazine. Just sayin' :popCorn:
 
I though pistol whiping was a hollywood trope. Back in the days of blackpowder when you ran out of shots you switched to a sword.

Shouldnt this post be directed to RL1 asking what sort of blade we should be attaching to our handguns? Or perhaps what sort of handguns we should be attaching to our blades?
 
Once in awhile (it usually happens when I should be working) - an irrelevant and unrelated asynchronous thought will pop into my head with all the abruptness of an echoing popcorn fart in a large empty room: it's not something to lose sleep over but it does demand inordinate amounts of processing power from the higher brain functions... Didjya ever notice that hardly anybody ever gets pistol whipped anymore?

When I was a kid even the vilest of villains could be sent to on a sprawling, painless trip to La La Land with a nice easy clip behind the ear. For Matt Dillon and Festus it was like Captain Kirk putting his phasers on stun - the bad guys hit the ground like a sack of wet cement, and were promptly hog tied and properly hung or incarcerated after a hasty (but fair) trial. The Cartwrights weren't half bad at it either. I think Cullen Bohannon pistol whipped Mr. Durant (he should have shot that no-good sumbi*ch) but other than that - it seems that pistol whipping is no longer part and parcel of pistolcraft! Indiana Jones didn't even crack his whip or raise a fist when confronted by a scimitar wielding skunk - he just shot him with contempt and that was that for that!

I don't think it would surprise anyone to learn that I was pistol whipped on a regular basis. Back in the day our cap guns were as heavy and well made as anything you fellas have in the gun safe: they were all metal, maybe some plastic on the grips - and flashier than anything coming out of Les Baer's skunkworx! When it came time for Cowboys & Indians I was always a villain or an expendable sidekick because I was the youngest and one day I was caught thieving cattle or Billy McEwit's bubble gum - and he brought his cap firing .45 down on my noggin and I got laid out flat! I got 6 stitches out of that and then I got pounded again by the big kids because the incident led to our parents confiscating our guns, bikes and baseball mitts for a week!:redface:

So I'm looking at the guns these days and I am seeing a lot of bumpers on the auto gun magazines...and if you tried to goon a guy with a thick skull like yours Truly with such a weapon, he'd probably spit in your eye instead of folding up. And it seems every second revolver you see these days have the soft Hogue or Pachmyer rubber grips on them.

One is tempted to regard this as a joke (and for all intents and purposes that's the way it's written) - but for the black powder geeks this is serious business. When the swabbies were repelling pirates with their flintlock pistols, or going hand to hand with them on the beach you had one shot - and then your pistol's merit relied on it's handiness as a club! Question: does the modern pistol still have any merit in such a role? I think it might for the single actions and maybe some of the bigger magnums...but other than that...if you are in the soup and fighting your way out, once your pistol runs dry the best course of action, tactically speaking...is to throw it at your assailant!:confused:

Without a doubt the most intelligent and useful piece of information I've seen on CGN!!! However, with all due respect to the learned scribe ... the BEST tactical action is : "throw it at your assailant THEN ... RUN LIKE HELL!!!!!" BEST HUMOUR I've seen for a long time! Thanks for the memories!!!!!
 
A good friend of mine with actual experience in this field (undercover drug cop out of Miami) once commented to me that one thing he likes about the 1911 is that "once you whop somebody with one, they stay whopped".


But I think Chuck Haggard has a story about someone disabling a 1911 by pistol whipping somebody with it.

So I guess the moral of that story is...1911s are great when they work but differences in manufacturing make them potentially unreliable, even when used as clubs.
 
A good friend of mine with actual experience in this field (undercover drug cop out of Miami) once commented to me that one thing he likes about the 1911 is that "once you whop somebody with one, they stay whopped".


But I think Chuck Haggard has a story about someone disabling a 1911 by pistol whipping somebody with it.

So I guess the moral of that story is...1911s are great when they work but differences in manufacturing make them potentially unreliable, especially when used as clubs.

How's that?
 
I remember, about 20 years ago or so, Soldier of Fortune magazine had an article about a 1911 that had a spike built into the butt for this exact purpose. The same gun also had some sort of device/bumper like thing built into the front end so that if the muzzle was pushed into flesh he slide wouldn't get pushed back and be unable to fire.
The point is that this gun was built with pistol whupping in mind from the get go.
 
As Charles Askins Sr. said to Jr.
Next time you pistol whip someone ,use a gun with a longer barrel.
You can swing it harder.
 
I remember, about 20 years ago or so, Soldier of Fortune magazine had an article about a 1911 that had a spike built into the butt for this exact purpose. The same gun also had some sort of device/bumper like thing built into the front end so that if the muzzle was pushed into flesh he slide wouldn't get pushed back and be unable to fire.
The point is that this gun was built with pistol whupping in mind from the get go.

Man, I bet that much stupid didn't come cheap.
 
A gentle tap to get persons attention may be fine, but a bag of meat is put together better than most would assume. A good whack up side the head could very well bugger your gun. It would be prudent to make sure your out of ammo before you resort to using it as a club.
 
Arsie----------whut?
Dem blokes beet'n yer nogg'n hazz plumb madeya a wee bit simple......... :cool:
Back in the days of your, they dint ahf tazzers and such.
Nutt'n like a fine cuff up the back side le tete Gibb's style.............:slap:
 
Back
Top Bottom