Fuddiness is a term I embrace full heartedly. I guided a few short barrels in BC mountain hunts (and many braked rifles for that matter), and I can say with certainty they are downright concussive to be beside and indiscernible from each other. As the guy beside the shooter glassing I couldn’t tell a difference between a short barrel on a bore .30 and under and a brake, either shake up the snot in your sinuses. .338s get a pass as case capacity wise to bore, they aren’t really a mag but just a well balanced cartridge. Usually I don’t hear or feel the shot hunting as guide or shooter, but I certainly do notice the short barrels and brakes even in the moment and I don’t remember them fondly.
Really depends if you’re an avid hunter, or an avid gun nut. You can be right down the middle too. I’m drifting from the former to the latter, and will now entertain setups that would be silly if the prime concern was effectively taking game out here with minimum fuss, simply because they’re interesting and I like toying around with different setups. That is to say the guns can be heavier, more complicated, louder, sillier, and more fun. I’ve hunted with some goofy setups over the years, and encourage diversity in approaches. Would be an awfully boring world if we all shot what makes the most sense, an off the rack 22-26” 7 1/2lb 7mm or .30 cal. Oddly enough, the guys I guided that were on a calendar of hunts and a mission so to speak despite having the means for whatever they wanted, typically hunted quite basic setups like that. It was all about the hunting not the guns.
Here, it’s about the guns, it’s why we gather here. So might as well get weird, niche and fun with em.