Sig Mosquito or S&W .22lr???

#1 I do a great deal of shooting. And when I am shooting a piece of crap like the Mosquito I turn to the internet and or other experienced gun owners to see if they are having the same problems or is it just my gun. When you read, assuming you can it gives you a broader insight to the larger picture.

Generally and for the most part anyone who has had opportunity to own or fire a Mosquito has the same problems or observations. Now I may be wrong about the gun being accurate but I shoot .22 freehand at 25 + yards. Maybe you are shooting at 10 yds and are having better luck. At 10 yds even the junk Sig Mosquito is a good gun, but so is a farmer with a shovel full of peas.

I assume if you got to this part of the letter ... you can read.
 
One Ontario dealer is no longer carrying the Mosquito due to the number or complaints/returns. I've fired a number of S&W 22's and although I prefer the Model 41 (and own one), the newer models are also reliable and reasonably accurate. I've also owned a High-Standard Victor which was extremely accurate but finicky on ammo, and have fired a number of brownings and rugers (all OK).

If you've really narrowed your choice to the two mentioned above I'd go for the S&W, but if you were asking more generally, I'd want to know:

Are you planning to do competitive target shooting?
Do you care about the LCF/tacticool esthetic?
Would you consider buying used?
What's your budget for this purchase?
Is this your first handgun?


/gc
 
Buy a cz kadet.I bought one last spring,it's a well built all steel pistol the kind that will last you a lifetime and you hand it down to your kids.I almost bought one of those pot metal pistols but decided for a few extra dollars get something that will last and has some resale value in case you ever want to sell it. Its the only pistol that feels like a full size combat pistol. I highly recommend it.

Yep ! the CZ 75 Kadet is really a good choice !! more I shoot with it more I love it :D
 
Thanks All for your input!!! Wow what great info. Pretty much I'm looking to do basic training and gain experience with a hand gun. I don't want any sort of expensive ammo or frustrating jamming. I want to torque up the trigger pounds to 10 or so and simply 'exercise'. I have no trouble buying used it is just a matter of from where. This would be my first handgun and so I do speak from a naive perspective. As for the budget, ideally I'd like to spend around $200 but if I have to go new then it looks like it would be about $300 - $400. Well I hope this helps with any further comments. Please keep them coming.
 
I had a Browning it was the worst POS I ever owned

Well, I've got an old Belgium made Browning Challenger that I've had for at least 20 years. I can't remember it ever choking on anything on failing to eject anything. It feels good in my hand and I shoot it well. In my experience its a hard act to follow.
 
I had a s&w 22A for a few seasons. I shot a bunch of our gun club's bullseye matches with it. I beat out everyone every match I went to. Average score per target was 90 with the lowest being a 80 and one beautiful 100 score (I still have the target).

The other guns in the competition were buckmarks, rugers, a s&w 617, and a s&w 41.

For the price I paid for it (I think it was around $350- $400) it was a gem to shoot. It fed almost any ammo, with the exception being remington golden bullets, and really shined with federal gold medal match.

The trigger was pretty decent out of the box and the grips were comfortable.

Take down is a breeze.

About the only gripe I can think of is that the firing pin will hit the barrel when dry fired. I put a little dent in the barrel when using remington bullets because the wouldn't feed properly.


I sold it to buy a ruger mark III competition government. I paid almost double the cost of the S&W has a heavier trigger and doesn't shoot any better or worse. I prefer the smith's target sites to the ruger's as well. I prefer the added weight of the ruger and the longer site axis though.


Bottom line I'd buy a 22A over the sig.
 
I'll open by saying that the Mosquito is sort of like that girl you have the hots for, but you know she is nothing but trouble and is going to put you through hell, but you still end up chasing the skirt.

I picked up the Mosquito as my first handgun and have spent an incredible amount of time reading and researching on it. I ended up deciding on it over several other popular 22lr handguns. The reasons will become clear later.

The Mosquito has some advantages and disadvantages. Depending on what you are looking for, the disadvantages may outweigh the advantages and vice versa.

The Mosquito has one major distinct disadvantage: The gun is *very* picky with ammunition.

The gun comes with two recoil springs, one softer / longer, and one shorter / stiffer spring.

Shooting "regular" ammo such as the Fiocchi or hotter ammo such as CCI Velocitor, you need to use the softer / longer return spring, otherwise the Mosquito will simply not cycle properly.

Strangely, the choice of ammunition also effects the mags, in the sense that the way that the rounds stack and feed from the mags they can stick or get misaligned a little.

With all of the ammo I was putting through it, the Mosquito was very unhappy and unreliable.

FTC and FTF at least once a mag.

Depending on your temperament, this can become very aggravating very quickly.

Then my box of CCI Mini Mags arrived.

The Mosquito changes character once install the shorter / stiffer spring, and put on the tallest front sight and start shooting the Mini Mags.

The only way I can describe the incredible change is that Sig probably designed the Mosquito around the CCI Mini Mag round.

The ammo feeds, the gun shoots, everything is proper, just how you would expect. The gun finally comes into it's own.

The model I have is quite accurate (extended barrel sport model), but you have to work at it.

Tonight we cycled 600 Mini Mags through it and it did really well as my personal skill improved with the weapon. By the end of the night we were often shooting 1" groups at 15 feet. Please remember that I'm a new shooter :)

I know its not stellar compared to something like the Rugers that many people have, but it's not engineered to be a purpose built target pistol like the Rugers.

There's a few items that I feel were important in my decision in getting the Mosquito.

The Mosquito is very similar in looks to a regular pistol. This might seem vain, but it's actually important in that it doesn't just look the part, but also functions the part.

All the controls are very similar to that of a full size p226. A new shooter could use the Moquito and transition to something bigger with a p226 with very little relearning. This follows through with things such as take down and maintenance.

When you take a take down a Ruger target pistol for the first time, it's a little freaky. Maintenance of the Mosquito is very simple, and very similar to the p226s.

The other major factor for me was weight. The mosquito weighs only 10% less then a base model p226. When you are practicing a lot and burning ammo like crazy, it helps to have something that won't break the bank, but at the same token remains very similar in weight and controls.

When you transition back to a full size pistol like a p226, I believe a lot of that practice and familiarity is retained.

The points noted here greatly influenced my decision on purchasing the Mosquito. I don't have enough time behind the trigger to be able to say if I have made the right decision yet, but after putting the CCI Mini Mag trough her, I am completely satisfied with the purchase.

Apologies for making this so long, but I hope it is more informative then some others in the thread saying that the Mosquito is a terrible gun without being able to identify why, or how to correct it.

I hope that whatever you end up getting you enjoy and get the most of it.

Good luck.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom