What's the smallest cartridges ppl are using for edible small game?
I ask because I'm curious about a centerfire rifle for squirrels and bunnies and the odd coon or coyote. Basically between 22mag and the 22 Hornet ballistically. Ideally 25/20 would be perfect with cast bullets but the rim makes things more difficult.
I tried the 223 with trail boss but consistent accuracy proved difficult to obtain
Another thought/consideration is that the only problem with this approach is that you will need a big game license in your possession as Ontario MNR COs will assume you are hunting that species if you get stopped with a centrefire. It may not be an issue, but could be a shocker if you don't hunt everything that walks, crawls and slithers.
I've shot alot of grouse with Primer charge .22 cal pellets from .22 Hornet cartridges. You would be surprised at how much accuracy and energy you can get from the Primer charge alone. Just size the neck, prime the case, press the pellet fully into the neck and you are done... Beeman Kodiak 14.2 grain pellets worked best for me, but others work as well... I tried about 15 different pellets... Beeman Silver Arrows worked good too and are a little heavier... no great trick to head shoot grouse and rabbits at 10-15 yards. I used a scope with multiple stadia lines so that there was an actual aiming point and avoided the hold-over guessing.
I tried trailboss in the 223 but I just not seeing the accuracy under 1800fps. Surprisingly 69gr tipped match kings shot straight to 100 yards in my 1 in 9 twist at 1800fps. No keyholing but gave about 3" group
Left to right,
.22 CCM (centerfire .22 Mag for all intents and purposes)
.22 Hornet
.221 Fireball
.223
5.6x50R Mag
A FP lightweight .224 bullet, 45grs or under, or the 33 Vmax, will shoot much better at Trail Boss velocities indeed. All about stabilization.
Far be it for me to talk anyone out of picking up a new rifle and cartridge, but have you considered (in the mean time) using a much lighter bullet in your rifle to potentially negate any keyholing issues? I've tried 50-55 grain bullets with Titegroup in the past in the 223. AFAIR, it was very accurate. Bluedot can also work well in these situations for dial a velocity.