So far I like the Tagua leather. The holster is very nice, the imprint is reasonably firm but the holster itself is supple enough to be comfortable. I like this model as the front sight doesn't protrude out the bottom so nothing to snag and it draws cleanly.
The mag holder, on the other hand is a bit on the tight side and needs to wear in to get fast draws. Also, the back of the snaps is not leathered over inside the holder so it's possible the mag bodies might get scratched, though with stainless mags this isn;t an issue really. with blued mags it would matter more.
Can't say anything bad about the holster though. I like it much better than my safariland Duty holster.