I think you'll like them. I have the black granulate one on my Gen3 G17 and I'm glad I got them . Very positive grip. I may have been happier with the rubber texture as the the sandpaper is a little aggressive but I can't complain. They took me about 1/2 hour to get on , heating the grip and forming it to my liking. Easy to take off and priced well. I found mine on eBay because I was having a hard time getting them elsewhere. Great product though, hope you enjoy