Would you believe that the PPCLI stock set came back to me. I opened my email and the set came back on a buy now for $225 shipped. The deal with someone else fell through I guess. The set has all the wood and all the hardware.
The Second Chance Offer on eBay is a legitimate tool, used by sellers when they have more than one item to put up, or if the top bidder backs out or gets suspended, etc. Just make sure it's not a spoof directing you to another site; if it's an eBay web address it's legit., and you should be able to access it through your My eBay page without even clicking on the link.
If the bidding got out of hand on that set, it wouldn't be surprising that the winner and under-bidder who drove it up finished with cold feet, and thus the offer comes to you if the seller doesn't want to wait for a re-list and
another frenzy fiasco with a chance of the same results.
You DO have eBay/(FRAUD ALERT) Buyer Protection on it just the same as any other transaction on those sites, for what it's worth. It can be a hassle to go through, but the buyer usually has a lot more power in their dispute process.
I haven't checked the original auction, and don't know the seller, but there *could* be potential problems. Maybe he saw how much more he got for it than expected, and said ‘I've got more of these; might as well sell 'em while they're hot!’ Except the other items aren't
exactly the same as the first one listed, and he's too stupid or lazy to know the difference. Or maybe anyone ahead of you backed out when a previously un-disclosed defect came to light.
Best to communicate with the seller and clarify that you are getting the original one listed, with the markings as pictured, and complete with the hard-ware, and he didn't drop and crack it in the mean-time.