Thoughts on the Kimber SVT .223 / Howa Short Action .204R Heavy barrel

.22LRGUY

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
177   0   1
Location
Ontario
Hey guys~rather than start two threads, I'm wondering if anyone here has either of these rifles and can comment on their accuracy potential with hand loads. No, I'm not looking for a comparison as I have a pretty good idea that the build quality is vastly different in both. I've owned a Cooper .204 and have a hunch the Kimber is in that ballpark from a quality POV. That particular Cooper was an accurate rifle, but took allot of effort at the reloading bench to wring every ounce out of it.

Anyhow, I have a VERY accurate .223 (Savage 10, "precision 10" carbine, 20" barrel) that shoots little bugholes from the bench but I could see upgrading to a snazzier rifle for groundhog duty in the future. However, not if the SVT leaves anything on the table accuracy-wise. If a Savage 20" barrel can shoot that well, is it reasonable to expect an 18" Kimber to shoot AS well...let alone, better? I know all the extra $ buys better fit/finish/materials but I'd never spring for one if it doesn't at least rival the Savage's accuracy.

The Howa~I've read some positive reviews on the rifle and would love to hear from anyone who has one, especially in .204R. Everything I've read suggests it's a 1:12" twist, but I'd really like a .204 that shot 32gr. V-Max best. I've never owned a Howa, but that Mini Action might be what makes me try one. Again, lighter bullet offerings are preferred and I'm hoping to find out that the M-A likes them best.

Anyhow, looking for any/all input related to these two rifles. Much appreciated.
 
I've had several Howas/Vanguards in several chamberings, and all have been unfailingly trouble-free and accurate. My only current one is a .270 Vanguard Deluxe which is a sub-MOA gun with almost any decent 140gr load. These guns just plain work, and work well.

I've also had a few Kimbers, including a SVT in .223 and a rimfire SVT .22lr. With one exception they have all been accurate guns, and they've all had problems: ejection issues, feed problems, inconsistent triggers, you name it. I constantly hear about how great Kimbers are...and I really, really want to like them, because they handle beautifully and feel wonderful...and I am probably going to give them one more try because a Montana in .243, if it functions well, is probably close to my Ideal Coyote Rifle...but I will never trust them completely, and I will never go on an important hunt with one simply because the confidence just isn't there.

So I agree with you, there is a huge difference in quality.
 
Back
Top Bottom