Hi there and welcome into the world of reloading.
In my experience, the decision to crimp or not has always been based on a few criterias :
- Am I reloading with a progressive machine that has a case mouth expander on the powder station - If so, crimpring would be required to remove the bell from the case mouth after seating the bullet.
- If I am loading by hand, and there is no case mouth flaring, is the caliber a heavy recoiling one where the bullet could be moving in or out the casing with the recoil, if it wasn't crimped?
- Still if I am loading by hand, will the cartridge hit a very steep feed ramp (like a Glock) or will it be almost aligned with the barrel when in the magazine (Beretta 92)
- Am I using a slow burning powder that would burn better / cleaner if the pressure builds up more before the bullet leaves the casing?
I am personally crimping all my handgun ammo (either taper crimp on pistol cartridges, or roll crimp on revolver cartridges)
For rifle ammo, I crimp most of it (especially ammunition that will be used in a semi-automatic rifle), leaving only my bolt-action precision rounds uncrimped.
Hope it helped.