So you don't think that someone who OWNS the land should be able to control that land? That they shouldn't be allowed to say who goes on the land and who doesn't? You own your home, should I be able to come in any time and do what I want? Land is PRIVATE PROPERTY, the owners can allow or restrict access as they wish.
We hunt on land that is marked "No Hunting" because we have permission from the landowner. They can recind that permision any time they want.
No I don't think the landowners should NOT be allowed to control their land, of course they should be allowed... you are missing the point. Back East I'm pretty sure that when the rules came out regarding posting of private land it was written that if you want to have someone charged with either tresspassing or hunting, the only way someone could be charged is if the land was posted properly.
I.E. if it is not posted NO HUNTING then you can hunt.. But if you decide to post your land NO HUNTING, it had to be done correctly, with NO HUNTING signs clearly posted at certain distances apart (every telephone pole, or 50 feet something like that??) And once you decided to post a parcel of land NO HUNTING... That is what that means.. NO HUNTING. I am pretty sure that land posted NO HUNTING MEANS no one can hunt... period.
Now if the land owner wanted to post his land NO HUNTING, but with an option to HUNT with PERMISSION, then WHY THE #### DO YOU NOT SEE THE OWNERS NAME AND NUMBER ON THE SIGN?
A NO HUNTING sign only gives one message to someone driving by looking for a place to hunt...
What your saying that you hunt land that is posted NO HUNTING because you have the landowners permission makes no sense. If it's posted no hunting, and you still hunt with permission, then that land owner used the wrong signs, or maybe this landowner DID post contact information I DON'T KNOW YOU DID NOT SAY! But likely he did not and you just happen to know him or they are family, not sure, but for someone driving out in the country trying to find out how to contact the land owner it aint easy if you are not in the know. So a NO HUNTING sign to me is a LOUD AND CLEAR message.
The signs then should say No Tresspassing and provide contact information, so that someone can then ask permission to hunt.
Or NO HUNTING WITHOUT PERMISSION, and provide contact info so you can ask...
NO HUNTING MEANS JUST THAT.... and if I am wrong, then so be it, but morally and ethically I Am Correct...