Top Three Non-1911 .45 ACP Pistol?

I can't name my top three, but I'd take an M&P .45 three times... ;)

With all due respect to the 1911, I'd prefer the M&P over it every time. Great ergonomics, 10-round mag, no manual safety lever and a better Safe-Action trigger than the Glock [IMHO], esp. after you put in an Apex service kit. My only caveat is that it may be a touch large for small hands.
 
1) HK45
2) M&P45
3) Sig 220

Early G21s had parts breakage issues but later models improved. The 20/21SF frame is pretty good.

The USPs that I have shot have had triggers that I did not like but they are extremely robust pistols.

The 3rd gen S&W autos (i.e. 4506 etc) are also good guns but heavy and I don't know how easy it would be to get parts now.

I can't think of another non-1911 .45 that I would recommend. I don't know much about the FN pistols.
 
I am surprised that no one have mentioned best of them all.

HK Mark 23

I don't mind shooting Sig 220 and Glock 21.

LOL. Accept no substitute.

Just make sure you have giant hands - please note size difference with the Glock 17 and M&P.... But yes its an incredibly accurate combat pistol out of the box.


 
As long as you don't mind owning a gun where a hundred thousand of them had to be recalled because shaking them too hard made them go off without the trigger being pressed, the Taurus is a pretty good pistol. Just carry it very carefully, and use a holster lined with a few inches of soft foam. Other than that, no downsides.

Well, the warranty issues, I guess. But other than the warranty and the fact that it might shoot you for no reason, great gun.
 
SIG 220 Out of the box it has an excellent trigger and a great sight picture. Shoots many different loads very well.

S&W M&P45 Needs an Apex trigger, and for me, a narrower FO front sight.

S&W 625
 
Listed in order of preference (yes I own them)

- H&K USP .45 (mine and the wife's fav)
- SIG P220 (great for smaller hands)
- Glock 21 Gen 4 (also good for smaller hands, cost is best of all!)
 
I've owned pretty much every .45 auto handgun (models) made including a number of copies of each and have cut it all back to two:

S&W 625
Glock 21SF
 
Back
Top Bottom