What's your goal with the trigger? Just a cleaner break, smoother pull, or a specific pull weight? Polishing the hammer strut wouldn't affect the trigger pull in any noticeable way really. If you felt any difference it would have been from the bow. 1911 triggers are a tricky pickle. Unfortunately just throwing random fire control parts with no specific goal at the problem won't work out very well. It takes a detailed understanding of how every part moves, and works with one another. That will take time, but it's not impossible. I spent countless hours reading up on trigger work and the do's and don'ts, and I still had a very difficult time getting it all right the first time I tried.
If your looking to change the look of the hammer and whatnot, then you will need a new sear. The 2 parts should be made by the same manufacture in order to maintain the same surface hardness. If your hammer is harder than your sear, it will start to round it off. They come oversized, meaning they will have to be fit to the pistol, and the sear and hammer geometry must be cut to perfectly mate together. That involves cutting your sear nose and hammer hook heights to proper dimensions. If this step is skipped, than ordering those new parts was just a waste of money. There is a good chance that the disconnector would need to be replaced in order to function with the new hammer and sear, as well as be properly fit and polished. Then comes the trigger, you can use a stock trigger, but it's heavy, non adjustable and the bow will not be square. Aftermarket trigger and bow would be recommended. But like previously, it would have to be cut and fit to the pistol. As well as cleaning and polishing the trigger tracks. The sear spring can be left stock, and polish contact surfaces. It can be tweaked to adjust pull weight. All of these steps require specialized tools.
I'll tell you out of my own experience, I tried to do most of that work without the proper research and tools the first go around, and had to end up redoing everything. Invested in the jigs, and stones and time. And I ended up with an incredible trigger pull. It was worth the investment because I ended up doing several more triggers on friends and families 1911's. If this is your only one, take it to a smith. Believe me.