Stef. You have to consider a few things,
1,Current Colt MSRP is $1,416.00
2,Current Blue Book Value on a 100 per cent gun is $1,225.00
3, The third Gen 44 Special and 357 Mag were discontinued around 1983.
4,Cowboy action shooters want 44-40 or 45 Colt, and Cowboy Action has pretty much fizzled out. Ask any gun shop.
5,Guys who are shooting you high numbers are talking not as Buyers with cash in hand (which I am)but only their personal opinion.
I tell you this from personal experience as I sold a 44 special a few years back and experienced these factors. I am looking for a replacement and I am interested if you want to sell but in the 12 to 14 hundred range.
I hope this is somewhat helpful, if anyone disagrees tell them to show you the money. Best Regards. Dave.