Well neither of us actually have any numbers, so I guess it could all be considered theories. I do agree that the warranty is abused for sure and I have also overheard a salesman use that exact phrase. You can't fix stupid and they don't teach common sense in school.
I have experienced a 33% failure rate....... I have owned leupold, zeiss and Nikon scopes and never had to use the warranty..... heck, even a couple of bushnell banners I had when I couldn't afford better performed well on a black powder rig and a 223....
It raises my eyebrow when I use a $200 torque screwdriver and torque to their specs and they still tell me I bent the tube...... I even took the caliper to the last one I sent in to look for irregularities in the tube and found none.....
I pay good money for hunts and can't afford a scope pooching out on me..... the "buck of a lifetime" thing is not drama..... In my experience it could very well happen......





















































