"we are using the Turkish manufactured copy of Benelli"

Everyone’s dumping on Turkish-made firearms.

Remember, plenty of Canadian-made firearms have turned out to be problematic, while others have proven extremely reliable. The Colt Canada C8 is a good example of the latter.

Turkish firearms are no different. They range from absolute garbage to military-grade firearms like the MKE MPT-76, SAR 109T and SAR 762 MT.

In my opinion Turkey is way ahead of Canada in firearms production.
Turkish shotguns are sort of like Indian immigrants in Canada. They used to have a decent reputation until a poorly vetted massive influx ruined the collective reputation of the whole lot for many people. Alot of the big name brands that get stuff made in turkey actually put in the effort and demand higher QC. More smaller and newer companies however, do not. i dont think the negative reputation of turkish guns is disproportionate to peoples first hand experience with turkish guns. I'd love for that reputation to improve, however that's going to take alot of work. The issue at hand in this particular thread IMO is the thinly veiled implication that benelli m4 clones as suitable for the battlefield. That simply is not the case and im sure you would agree. For the range they are fun toys so long as people understand that they are buying a cheap knock off to satisfy a fun itch without breaking the bank, i have no issues with that whatsoever.
 
At first there were some ok guns for light use coming from Turkey under some of the bigger brands like CZ, Weatherby, Stoeger, Webley. Huglu has been around for quite a while. I wondered at the influx of new names there, probably 10-12 yrs ago, the Retay Benelli copy, etc. Guess it's much the same as what happened with the Spanish guns 50yrs ago, had some good ones around, and some krap ones. Not sure about Brazilizn stuff, it's been around a long time, but has never really, that I recall, had any brands that developed a good rep. I have a CZ/Huglu gun, it's into 4-5 cases of 3" 20ga now, still working OK, doesn't owe me anything, I'd say I have had my money's worth out of it. Not sure I ever heard the story on why Prophet got out of Huglu, didn't seem to be because they weren't selling.
 
I've watched real m4's fail to cycle
While I admit their are Turkish brands to avoid there are others that make a quality products
Chiappa is itialian but not all itialian guns are junk
Shooting cheap ass birdshot? My gun now long since broken in, will cycle anything…even rusted, no longer round shells…as long as they are a proper semi auto loading, not a 87 year old man’s #9 trap loaded into a 2” shell
 
Turkish shotguns are sort of like Indian immigrants in Canada. They used to have a decent reputation until a poorly vetted massive influx ruined the collective reputation of the whole lot for many people. Alot of the big name brands that get stuff made in turkey actually put in the effort and demand higher QC. More smaller and newer companies however, do not. i dont think the negative reputation of turkish guns is disproportionate to peoples first hand experience with turkish guns. I'd love for that reputation to improve, however that's going to take alot of work. The issue at hand in this particular thread IMO is the thinly veiled implication that benelli m4 clones as suitable for the battlefield. That simply is not the case and im sure you would agree. For the range they are fun toys so long as people understand that they are buying a cheap knock off to satisfy a fun itch without breaking the bank, i have no issues with that whatsoever.
Exactly, they are what they are…. You would think North Sylva would understand this and not overhype them to avoid disappointed customers if they get a lemon.
 
They prob work ok for the Ukrainian army because they don’t use weak crap ammo so the guns will cycle but they prob don’t get a good amount of rounds per gun life
Does the solider outlive the gun or does the gun outlive the soldier…
 
3dram 1 1/8oz top gun and gun clubs
People often use M4s on the trap field?

They are not made for birdshot but if can work 98% of the time once broken in and held correctly…you are also (well shouldn’t be) using birdshot in a dangerous situation of any kind so it not “working” is kinda moot IMO.

You can also make them fail using a very light grip, and not pulling it into your shoulder…have seen new shooters, scared of recoil make them barely cycle as a semi auto…not just an M4 thing, most semi shotguns can suffer from this, kinda a shotgun version of a “limp wrist”.
 
I bought a Stevens 555 20ga o/u about 8 or so years ago. I have no complaints with that Turkish shotgun. Fit and finish is excellent. Atm it's my favourite grouse gun when strolling the out of use bush roads. 🤷‍♂️
I have a Yildiz side by side in 20ga that I’ve enjoyed grouse hunting with for many years as well.
 
A buddy and i both bought the OG Turkenelli's that SJ Hardware brought to market. I think i had one failure, shooting slugs off a rest when my pack bounced a hull back towards the operating handle and interrupted the cycling. Other than that it has eaten everything, from the cheapest ####tiest Walmart aluminum low brass ammo to low recoil slugs to buckshot and anything else I could feed it. Is it a Benelli? Of course not. But it has been reliable. Shotguns are pretty low priority in my gun safe so spending big B money wasn't in my wallets interest.
 
Most of the Turkish shotguns I have owned I ended up selling except my MC312. On the other hand my Stevens 334 in .243 (rebranded Turqua) is like a fine Swiss watch next to my gen 1 Ruger American! I know that Ruger has a long standing rep for quality and robust builds but the American reminds me of the first years of the Savage Axis. Basically the basement of the rifle market. The chatter marks on the barrel of my American are so deep that I have to pull the tufts of lint off it after using it. The internal machining is no better, closing the bolt sounds like the zipper on my winter coat!
 
You see, Ukraine never needed our cucked firearms, they just needed our $1B in tax dollars to help manufactuer their own firearms.

So don't worry, when the EU intergtation takes effect & the age of conscription is raised to 65 like in certain parts of the EU.

We will all have a chance to use an AR again. 🤣😂
 
After having felt it was such an overblown sentiment, I bought a canuck tacop elite.

I was much less than thrilled and sold it after putting half a box of shells through it. Felt like an airsoft gun. I've since learned to just save up for the quality alternative. Not every gun has to be bought with a rely on it for your life mindset, but it takes the enjoyment out of things when you have to worry about whether or not it'll just work reliably and not feel like its falling apart.
Did it fail to cycle? Fail to fire? Anything break? Was it inaccurate?

What made it “feel like an airsoft gun”?
 
I have a 14” hatsan that I have beaten the #### out of enough over years to trust it. I have a collapsing stock and a birds head grip for it. If it was going to break, it would have by now . I have another Turkish semi auto copy of something that I forgot that I owned. It’s less reliable, but in a gravel pit style trap shoot, it’s worth bringing out once in a while. Looks cool but meh on performance. It was maybe 300 though. Worth it for ####s and giggles.
 
JorkinMyBait I'm trying to understand this. you felt the same as a guy who had a no Turkish gun policy, you then went and bough one, and it was meh, poor quality and you were worried it would fall apart, yet later in this same thread you speak and say you have had 4 of them. If it was crap, why would you buy 4. Most large names, sell stuff made in turkey. I've had a few, and they were fine, none of them Felt like they were going to fall apart.
 
Back
Top Bottom