I was able to handle the Tikka and the Vangaurd the other day. The Tikka is lighter with a detachable mag, bolt throw has a shorter arc, points really nice. The Vangaurd is a little muzzle heavy which should balance out with a scope on, floor plate mag. nicer feeling stock. I would choose the Tikka for the detachable mag. Our Savage dealer is out of stock, so that says allot as well for that brand.