Plinker, you can include me in there, too. I knew a few of those men, actually had several for friends, despite the difference in ages.
Normally, they would never talk about the War, but if you got them relaxed and they knew that you were honestly seeking knowledge, they would open up a bit. The one thing that never ceased to amaze me was the sheer level of privation those men lived under, and with, and for so very long. Take just that, then add in the level of casualties, then think about the actual fighting and the conditions it was undertaken under....... and you begin to wonder why any of them returned home even remotely sane.
The recent film "Passchendaele" gives an idea what it must have been like, but even that was very clean when you compare it with the original newsreels. Kirk Douglas's 1960s production "Paths of Glory" is about the French Army in the events leading up to the Mutinies; it's rough, but even that isn't bad enough.
Here's a point to remember: when you're digging a trench, the dirt has to go somewhere. You heap up dirt in front, some of it in sandbags, and that's the parapet. But you still have a lot of dirt, so you throw it behind your trench; that's the parados. The French lost 300,000 men at Vimy Ridge and the enemy fire was so bad that they couldn't even take the dead out for a proper burial, so they stuffed a lot of them into the parados and lived just a few feet from their own decomposing buddies. The British had a go at the Ridge, but they just generated more casualties. Then it was the Canadians' turn. By that time the trenches were pretty beaten-up and a whole new trench system had to be dug.... and it was..... sometimes right through the remains of French soldiers who had died there 2 years before. And the rats were huge... and you know what they had been eating.
Small wonder those men wouldn't talk much about it. When I went to interview my old friend Pte. Rollie Hart (Nfld. Regiment, 1914 - 1919) regarding the War, it was supposed to be just about the LAST day, what it was like for him. He was born on November 11, 1896, so the cease-fire took place on his 22nd birthday. He said many times that the War had ended on his birthday, not the other way around, and he offered the opinion that the only reason it ended was because he was such a helluvva nice guy. "There was no other reason for it to end," he would say, "We all thought that it was going to go on forever." When I turned up at his house to do the actual interview for the newspaper, Rollie met me at the door with a 40-ouncer in his hand. He dropped the cap into he woodstove and pointed toward the empty 26 on the table and said, very quietly, "A man has to be drunk to tell the truth of it. I'm only half drunk, so I'm only going to tell you half the truth."
That was 59 years after the shooting stopped.
Yeah, you can put me in with the modern generation. Those men were HARD. They had to be, just to survive. And then they came back and built this country.. and look at it now.
.