What semi-auto chambering would you choose?

If you could have only 1 semi-auto which cartridge would you choose?

  • 9mm

    Votes: 45 24.5%
  • .38 Super

    Votes: 3 1.6%
  • .357 Sig

    Votes: 2 1.1%
  • .40 S&W

    Votes: 29 15.8%
  • 10mm Auto

    Votes: 24 13.0%
  • .45 ACP

    Votes: 81 44.0%

  • Total voters
    184
RudyH,
You're kidding right? its only about 2 inches longer and probably an inch taller. Lets not forget that its close to 2 inches thick. Weighs in at over 3.5 pounds, nearly 4.5(if I remember correctly) loaded in 50AE. They're prone to failure, they fit nearly no one, the sights are ass, and the magazine capacity is rather small. But hey, if you really wanna carry that be my guest. :)

TDC
 
I'd be inclined to go with 10mm but are Double Tap, Buffalo Bore and other hot 10mm makes even available in Canada? If not I'd rather stick with the .45rather than bother with the sheep in wolf's clothing that are most 10mm offerings.

As far as any handgun and bear go I see even heavily loaded .41s, .44s and .45s as being weapons of last resort, I actually felt a bit undergunned coming up against a brown bear with a 12 gauge full of Foster slugs.
 
This thread lost all COMMON sense when the 9mm was selected as a WOODS protection cartridge.....

Not just once but 32 times???

LAUGHABLE!

Some people on here need to do a little research on the round they would intend to trust their lives too.

Once again from the FBI's own research...

13. Are you saying the 9mm is no good??
No. We are saying it is as good as the .38 Special which has served us for a long time.
It has severe limitations which we are not willing to accept. It is woefully inadequate
for shooting at people in cars, for example, and over half of our shootings involve
vehicles. It is a marginally adequate wounding agent. We have had a number of 9mm
shootings over the past couple of years, and if you define a good shooting as one in
which the subject stops whatever he was doing when he gets shot, we have yet to have a
good one, and we are hitting our adversaries multiple times. We have shot half a dozen
dogs in the past year and have not killed one yet, although we have run up a significant
veterinary bill.
The 9mm with proper ammunition is not a bad round. It is just nowhere
near as effective as the 10mm and .45 offerings, and the disparity between it and the
larger calibers has remained a constant throughout all the testing we have done over the
past two years.



FBI Miami shootout, 1986

On April 11, 1986, a shootout occurred in Miami, Florida, between multiple FBI agents and two heavily armed suspects. Later known as the FBI Miami shootout, the firefight claimed the lives of two agents, Gerald Dove and Benjamin Grogan, as well as the two suspects, William Matix and Michael Platt. Five other agents were injured.

The incident is infamous: despite outnumbering the suspects, the agents found themselves pinned down by rifle fire, and the suspects were not incapacitated by repeated hits from handguns, and continued to fight after being shot.





Background
The FBI agents were investigating a series of violent bank robberies, and had reason to believe the suspects drove a 1979 Chevrolet Monte Carlo. On April 11, agents manned ten cars on the lookout for the suspect vehicle. At about 9 a.m., Grogan and Dove spotted the vehicle, and began to follow it. Several other cars joined them, and eventually an attempt was made to stop the suspect car, which was forced off the road. The shootout then began.


Weapons
Suspects
Ruger Mini-14 rifle
S&W M586 .357 Magnum revolver
Dan Wesson .357 Magnum revolver
S&W M3000 12 gauge shotgun
FBI
Smith & Wesson .357 and .38 Special revolvers
S&W 459 9mm pistols
Remington 870 12 gauge shotgun

The shootout
Immediately after being forced off the road, Platt began firing the Mini-14 from the car, while Matix fired a single round from the shotgun. Matix was soon hit twice by the agents, and he was apparently knocked unconscious. He fired no more shots throughout the battle. Platt, however, had already injured two agents with the rifle.

Platt climbed out a car window, and was soon hit several times, yet he continued fighting, now firing a revolver. He also continued to use the rifle, despite injuries to his right hand and arm, and caused agents more injuries, including a shot to the neck.
Military-trained, Platt aggressively advanced on Grogan and Dove's car, which they (so far uninjured) were using for cover. Reaching their position, he continued firing the rifle. Platt killed Grogan with a shot to the chest, shot another agent in the groin, and then killed Dove with two shots to the head. Platt himself had been hit six times at this point.
Platt entered Grogan and Dove's car, apparently attempting escape. He was joined by Matix, who had regained consciousness and crawled unseen to Platt's position.

The fight was ended by agent Edmundo Mireles, who, despite having been hit in the arm by Platt's opening shots, returned fire with his shotgun one-handed, then stood up and advanced directly towards the car, shooting six rounds of .38 Special from his revolver, hitting Matix three times and Platt twice. Both were finally killed.

Toxicology tests showed that the astounding abilities of Platt and Matix to fight through multiple traumatic gun shot wounds and continue to battle and attempt to escape were not achieved through any chemical means. Both of their bodies were completely drug- and alcohol-free at the time of their deaths.


Aftermath
Alarmed by the perceived lack of stopping power the FBI's 9mm service pistols exhibited, they soon began the search to adopt a more powerful caliber. Also noting the difficulties of reloading a revolver while under fire, they specified that agents be armed with semiautomatic handguns. The Smith & Wesson 1076 10mm Auto was chosen as a direct result of the Miami shootout.

Media
The events leading up to and including the April 11 shootout were adapted into a made-for-television movie, In The Line Of Duty: The FBI Murders, starring Michael Gross as William Matix and David Soul as Michael Platt.

The incident is prominently featured in the dissident novel Unintended Consequences by John Ross.

The film Heat is thought to be based upon this event.
 
Last edited:
I'm a fan of .40:

-easy to find
-many gun options
-many bullet options
-sufficient penetration
-in my mind best balance of power/cost
 
Jeff/1911 said:
Definitely a 10mm...that's a choice I don't have to think twice about. ;)


I couldn't say it better than that...

The 10mm can do everything the other standard production semi-auto rounds can do and everything they can't... :p
 
870P said:
I'd be inclined to go with 10mm but are Double Tap, Buffalo Bore and other hot 10mm makes even available in Canada? If not I'd rather stick with the .45rather than bother with the sheep in wolf's clothing that are most 10mm offerings.

As far as any handgun and bear go I see even heavily loaded .41s, .44s and .45s as being weapons of last resort, I actually felt a bit undergunned coming up against a brown bear with a 12 gauge full of Foster slugs.


I had an email corrispondence with Mike Mcnett of Double Tap Ammo and he told me that he will sell to us but can't ship over the border.

No problem for me I'd just have it shipped to my PO Box in the States then go down and pick it up... :D

But I would use reloads...
 
Camp Cook said:
I had an email corrispondence with Mike Mcnett of Double Tap Ammo and he told me that he will sell to us but can't ship over the border.

No problem for me I'd just have it shipped to my PO Box in the States then go down and pick it up... :D

But I would use reloads...

Camp,

I sent McNett another email this morning..

I asked for an update on Cdn. distribution for DoubleTap.

He told me last year."I am working on it".

But your right...

Approx 9.6 gr of IMR 800X should do the trick on everything up to and including Black Bear.:dancingbanana:
 
I'm sure you'll have the US export permit for the ammo in your pocket Eh!

Otherwise US Law will be broken, and such illegal activities can NOT be discussed on CGN.

Cheers.

Camp Cook said:
I had an email corrispondence with Mike Mcnett of Double Tap Ammo and he told me that he will sell to us but can't ship over the border.

No problem for me I'd just have it shipped to my PO Box in the States then go down and pick it up... :D

But I would use reloads...
 
Minimum caliber for black bear according to the Wilderness Handgun Course taught in Ontario for people wanting to carry a firearm in the wilderness in conjuction with there legal occupation (ie trapper, prospector) is:

357 mag. minimum for black bear
44 mag. minimum for grizzly bear

If you have ever seen a bears skull the forehead is a natual ramp to deflect round nose jacketed bullets. A bears eyes do not lead to the brain as on a human. The eyes of a bear are on pods on the outside of the skull so even a shot to the eye leaves you with a one eyed angry bear. The 44mag. round at the muzzle has bout the same energy as a 30-30 at about 200 yard. Check the balistic tables of various cartridge manufacturers. The 30-30 is regarded as a deer cartridge at closer ranges. Most of your common pistol rounds are not great bear rounds, especialy round nose jacketed. If you are looking for a handgun for bear stick to 44 mag. with semi wadcutters. It is also not very useful to shot a bear that is attacking you with a handgun if it does not stop it instantly. A wounded black bear can do a lot of damage to a human if it still has a minute or two to maul you before it dies. If a bear is attacking you it will be coming fast and head first, your targets are very limited. To stop a bear instantly you need the round to penetrate the skull and damage the brain. You could also place a shot to the spine which would stop it instantly. If the bear is on you and you still retain your handgun contact shot are more powerful, as not only the projectile enters the bears body but also the gas which will also do damage. Also remember that if you push the muzzle of a lot of semi-auto against something it pushes the slide out of battery and the firearm will not fire. Just my 2 cents worth.
 
Last edited:
Bud45223 said:
Minimum caliber for black bear according to the Wilderness Handgun Course taught in Ontario for people wanting to carry a firearm in the wilderness in conjuction with there legal occupation (ie trapper, prospector) is:

357 mag. minimum for black bear
44 mag. minimum for grizzly bear

.

The 10mm outperforms the .357 magnum in penetratration, sectional density and energy . The .40 is LARGER than .357 Mag and the 10mm is more powerful therefore the 10mm would do just fine according to the course.

DoubleTap .357 Magnum
125gr. Gold Dot JHP @ 1600fps - 12.75" / .69" (4inch barrel)
158gr. Gold Dot JHP @ 1400fps - 19.0" .56"(4 inch barrel)687 ft.lbs.




Just for ####s and grins ...taken from Speer #13.(6 inch barrel)

MAX velocity listed for 158gr is 1265 fps for a GD-HP(not an Ideal choice for large game)....therefore Doubletap's loading EXCEEDS Speer's max by 150+fps....so no argument can be made for handloading the .357 mag to exceed the 10mm. Unless you go above book data.


DoubleTap 10mm
135gr JHP @ 1600fps - 11.0" / .70" frag nasty
155gr Gold Dot JHP @ 1475fps - 13.5" / .88"748ft.lbs
165gr Gold Dot JHP @ 1400fps - 14.25" / 1.02"
165gr Golden Saber JHP @ 1425fps - 14.75" / .82"
180gr Golden Saber JHP @ 1330fps - 16.0" / .85"
180gr XTP @ 1350fps – 17.25” / .77”
180gr Gold Dot JHP @ 1300fps - 15.25" / .96"
200gr XTP @ 1250fps - 19.5" / .72"
230gr Equalizer @ 1040fps - 11.0" and 17.0" / .62" and .40"



You cannot argue with the numbers....

Yes, you are right .44 Mag would be better in most cases, but the purpose of the poll was to discuss carry-able semi-auto's ...

IMHO the 44 AutoMag, Desert Eagle are not carryable for everyday use.


Would I want to use a 10mm against a charging Black Bear Sow ....NO...

But out of the cartridges listed in the poll it WILL have the BEST chance at stopping her.
 
Last edited:
Halger280HVMag said:
I'm sure you'll have the US export permit for the ammo in your pocket Eh!

Otherwise US Law will be broken, and such illegal activities can NOT be discussed on CGN.

Cheers.


Of course I would how could you possibly think any other way... :cheers:
 
350 Mag said:
Just simply pointing out the fact the 10mm Auto is a do-it-all cartridge. Carry-able sized pistol, high capacity, accurate, powerful, and can be used for hunting deer sized game.

350 Mag, I can appreciate that you have a favorite handgun and caliber, but I think trying to make your point through a poll simply misled people into thinking that you were thinking of a realistic situation and looking for a realistic solution.

Nope, I have never personally tried to take down a charging black bear with a handgun, regardless of the caliber. Nor do I have the intention of trying it out. But if you feel it may add weight to your argument in favor of the 10mm, feel free to try it out and to come back here to tell us about the results.
 
I picked the 10mm as well. I'd probably go with my Glock 20 which would be even better if we could use the standard capacity 15 round mags loaded with 200 grain Norma ammo...
 
The problem with most auto pistol cartridges is that the round that is the most reliable for feeding is the round nose. To break through a bears skull a semi-wadcutter would do a better job. It is hard to get an auto to feed the semi-wadcutter reliably, not impossible just harder. If your main concern is bear then I would stick to the 44 mag. with semi-wadcutter. Forget about hollow points in a handgun they are designed for shooting people.
 
Here is the link to my bullet of choice for the 10mm and the same one that Mike Mcnett of Double Tap loads...

http://www.beartoothbullets.com/bulletselect/index.htm then scroll down on the left menu bar to 10mm...

10mm/.38-40 Caliber 200g FN GC

Over All Length .612

Nose To Crimp .280

Meplat Dia. Diameters .310

I shoot these absolutely reliable feeding monster's @ 1300fps out of my 5" barreled Colt Delta Elite and G20 10mm's...

Not quite a 44mag but I'm looking at a lot of performance when I grab my 10mm handguns and load them up for bear encounters... :)

Awesome thumping round... :D

Yeah Baby... :runaway:
 
Unless I missed someone's post here, I didn't see any mention of using lead bullets.

I think you'd find that a handful of even 9mm heavy for calibre lead slugs dumped into a black bear would work OK.

Of the choices listed, I'd pick 10mm if I had to, but would be quite comfortable with a 45 loaded with 230gr lead bullets around 900fps, either a RN or FN design, provided I had tested feed reliability in my gun.
 
All nice cartridges, but 10mm and 357sig are harder to find ammo for.

Decades ago I spent about 4 months researching and dreaming about what I would choose for my first handgun. At that time I wasn't sure if I'd ever have more than one handgun (loud laughter), so I got a .45ACP Colt Combat Commander.

Even though that was many, many guns ago, I am still extremely fond of that caliber. It will get the job done.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom