What would YOU do?

Crashman

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
207   0   0
I have a little experience to share with you guys and ask your advice. My dad owns a farm in sourthern Ontario, 100+ acres, lots of deer, turkey, grouse, etc. I have two birds dogs and I bowhunt so I hunt almost anything in season.

Yesterday I was there cutting my next winter's wood, when I flush a grouse out the fence line, beautiful big male, flies over the fence and on to the neighbours where I hear a shot from an area of reforested pines that also hold lots of rabbits so maybe he shot at a rabbit at the same time as I flushed the grouse. Grouse season is closed however as it ends on December 31st. A few minutes later I hear a four wheeler start up and he is gone. I am back there this morining in the same spot and I see what I think is the same bird, so maybe he did not actually hit it.

Relations with this neighbour have always been strained as they have been there longer than my dad (my dad has owned this farm for 25 + years) and they feel that since the previous owner granted them permission to hunt there, we should just stay at home and not bother them. During the controlled shotgun/muzzleloader season, they always have a huge gang and shoot EVERYTHING they see, from fawns, to buttons and forkers, does and mature bucks, basically no thought for conservation or quality deer management. And they don't give a $hit if their guest hunters trespass onto my dad's land, and in fact one of their guests actually accused me of trespassing a few years ago...he did not know where he was and I quickly pointed out to him HE was in the wrong and HE should leave NOW.

So do I call the MNR or OPP? Do I let it go as I did not see him actually shoot AT the grouse and he could have been shooting at a rabbit instead. I know it is only a grouse, but at what point do we make a stand...what if it was a deer or a turkey? Are they more valuable than a grouse?
 
Post your land clearly and put up hidden trailcams to take pic's.Next time one of them tresspasses take the pic's to the authority's. If you have been trying to get along with them that long and they still disrespect your land there is no point in trying to be neighborly it just ain't going to work.
 
You have absolutely no proof or evidence that he took a bird out of season.

You're probably right that he took a shot at it, but what're the COs supposed to do at this point?

For future, post your land very well, and take down license plates of any vehicles on your property or parked next to your property. Report those asap.
 
I'd say make it clear the neighbors and their buddies are not to be on your turf... as far as reporting him for anything, I don't think you have a foot to stand on there. Hard to prove something that you didn't see.
 
Remember that these people are your neighbours and reporting them for shooting a grouse out of season could create quite a bit of tension between the two of you, not to mention cause them to act maliciously towards you, your father or the property. If no one is at the property on a regular basis, you leave yourself open to all kinds of devious acts that a p*ssed off neighbour might perpetrate.

I would post the property very well, document all trespassing and then approach the neighbour first, failing that call the OPP with your evidence, Police need evidence. Same for CO's, if you can't prove it don't bother reporting it.

Patrick
 
Remember that these people are your neighbours and reporting them for shooting a grouse out of season could create quite a bit of tension between the two of you, not to mention cause them to act maliciously towards you, your father or the property

Wouldn't slow me down at all from reporting them - IF you knew they shot at the bird.

As you say, you don't know what he was shooting at, or even if he was shooting at game. He could have been shooting at tin cans. Might not have even been the neighbor - could have been someone who entered his property without permission on an atv.

Doesn't sound like there's actually an 'event' here that you could take action on. Keep a weather eye for the future, but i think there's nothing here to do anything about.
 
I would have a chat with the neighbor and tell him that you will be clearly marking your property as "no trespassing", and you expect him to brief his guests accordingly when they are using his property.

If your property is fenced, that is implied no trespassing under the hunting regs in ontario. Put your signs up and paint your dots, and prosecute anyone that violates.
 
I would have a chat with the neighbor and tell him that you will be clearly marking your property as "no trespassing", and you expect him to brief his guests accordingly when they are using his property.

If your property is fenced, that is implied no trespassing under the hunting regs in ontario. Put your signs up and paint your dots, and prosecute anyone that violates.

Well said!
 
I think the issue here may be a little more serious than just taking a bird out of season (even though that is already serious). Do these guests check-in with you before hunting on your land? How about the neighbours? If I were you, I'd tell my neighbour that he or any of his guests would have to check-in with me before they hunt on my land, just so I know who is out there and doing what. It would suck for you to go for a little outing one day and be accidentally in a stranger's field of fire. I would also follow the above advice about making it clear where your neighbour's land end and yours begin.

As for the grouse incident. Unless you have solid proof he was shooting at the bird, I wouldn't report anything. Like the others have said, if you suspect them of hunting out of season and want to bust them, you can set up some surveillance.

I know a lot of farm owners in Ontario have problems with random people going into their land to fish, even during the off season.
 
Thanks for the advice guys, it all makes sense now. I guess when it happened I was so irritated it was hard to think about in a rational way. All I wanted to do was go there and scream at this guy and let him know I thought he was a slob and...well you get the picture.
 
As mentioned put up signs, but I would go a bit further. Build a few tree stands along the edge of your property line that meets his property, and invite a few friends to hunt with you(should not be hard to find peeps to hunt with u). The neighbors need to see your land is being hunted on. Many hunters decide they can hunt on other peoples land when they know the chance of running into anyone is slim.
 
This is my side


-----------------------

This is yours



Fence, barbed wire..... Deer / moose can jump several feet and birds dont care.
 
Dead easy question....

You TALK to the neighbors and say

This land is YOUR land and this land is MY land.

You or your hunters end up on MY land, then they will be charged.

Keep in mind, once you draw the line, it's done. SO if you shoot a deer on YOUR land,and it jumps into his territory, you need permission to retrieve it.
 
Remember that these people are your neighbours and reporting them for shooting a grouse out of season could create quite a bit of tension between the two of you, not to mention cause them to act maliciously towards you, your father or the property. If no one is at the property on a regular basis, you leave yourself open to all kinds of devious acts that a p*ssed off neighbour might perpetrate.

I would post the property very well, document all trespassing and then approach the neighbour first, failing that call the OPP with your evidence, Police need evidence. Same for CO's, if you can't prove it don't bother reporting it.

Patrick

Devious acts, my dad had a place in the country for a few years and the only way you could get there in the winter was to walk in or snow mobile. Seems a number of visits from the locals to do nothing more than destroy property was big fun for these hillbilly's. Place was never locked but they still had to bust down the doors, pee on the carpet and a number of other juvenille behaviors. Then when that wasn't any fun, lets break all of the windows, just pathetic. Where was this you say, less than 50 miles out of Edmonton. FS
 
Back
Top Bottom