Which gun would you sell?

Read the thread first

  • Sig P226ST

    Votes: 16 11.6%

  • S&W M&P9

    Votes: 38 27.5%

  • Beretta 92 Inox

    Votes: 31 22.5%

  • Taurus Raging Bull .44

    Votes: 41 29.7%

  • Keep what you have - none of the new options worth selling anything

    Votes: 12 8.7%
  • Total voters
    138
IM_Lugger

IM_Lugger

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
216   0   0
Location
Hamilton
I’m thinking of getting another gun - either 10mm 1911, EAA/Tanfoglio 10mm, Glock 20 OD or SIG P220 .45acp

Don’t have any spare cash, so would have to sell one of my toys first. I love them all so it would be tough…:(

From the guns listed above which one would you let go if you were me? Keep in mind resale value is important!

I know I'd have to figure it out for myself just curious what others think ;)
 
Well I voted for the Sig based on resale value. But then I noticed you have three ten round 9mm's there.
Which of those do you love to shoot the most?
If it becomes a tossup between the Beretta and the Sig, then sell the Sig or you will have to change your avatar.
 
If I were you I will sell the M&P just incase you buy the 220 so that you still have the 226 to pair with. M&P also doesn't look better than 92F and the Racing bull is one hell of hottest looking gun.

Trigun
 
35 votes and only 3 replys?! Come on guys let's hear some reasoning behind the votes....:)

If it becomes a tossup between the Beretta and the Sig, then sell the Sig or you will have to change your avatar.
Click to expand...
good point! :D
 
Last edited:
I think you need to keep your only revolver and your only black polymer. So it comes down to a choice between two stainless 9s, and I will always go with Sig over Beretta.

So the Inox (and a new avatar) got my vote.
 
I'd let the M&P go (I have had all 3 of the 9mm's and it was the one i sold) and go for the P220. I'm not a fan of the 10mm but to each his own. If I had the money the one other gun I'd like to add is the STI in 9mm from Armco.
 
OK this is where I stand...

92FS -- beautiful gun, soft shooting, been 100% - has the best track record of all.
M&P9 -- nice and light, reliable, has been growing a lot on me...
P226 -- probbaly has the best fit and finish of all, but otherwize doesn't offer anything the other two don't have.
Raging Bull -- only revolver and handcannon! looks great and gets a lot of attantion at the range. But doesn't make it to the range as often (semi-auto guy)
 
When in doubt, sell the plastic-fantastics! So I voted SW MP. I could never get attached to a polymer gun though... I had an XD9, good shooter, but I never really 'cared' about it.
 
"P226 -- probbaly has the best fit and finish of all, but otherwize doesn't offer anything the other two don't have."

It sounds like you answered your own question. No matter how nice a gun is if it doesn't make you want to shoot it it's just an expensive paperweight!

Sell the Sig, sell the Sig, sell the Sig! (shouted like "kill the pig" from Lord of The Flies):D
 
How many calibers can you afford to shoot?:eek: I would keep the 9mm M&P, sell the rest, and buy a G20. I would then start reloading for 10mm.
 
IM_Lugger said:
I’m thinking of getting another gun - either 10mm 1911, EAA/Tanfoglio 10mm, Glock 20 OD or SIG P220 .45acp

Don’t have any spare cash, so would have to sell one of my toys first. I love them all so it would be tough…:(

From the guns listed above which one would you let go if you were me? Keep in mind resale value is important!

I know I'd have to figure it out for myself just curious what others think ;)
Click to expand...


Resale value is excellent with the 226 (except for whoever sold the 226 ss for 600 a couple of days ago here...still can't figure that one). So sell the Sig ss and get the Sig 220. You still have other 9mm's and now a beautiful new Sig .45 to play with.
 
Sell the M&P9. While its resale value may not be as much as the other 9mm's, it will be the easiest to replace (should you regret selling it) with an M&P.40, which is what you should have bought in the first place.:p
 
If I was going to buy the new Sig, I would sell the Sig, but on the other hand I would probably keep what I have and try to scrape up enough cash to buy the new one, problem solved.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom