Which hunting rifle should I get?

I’ve had 5 lever guns over the years. Including a remlin 336 in 30-30. With crooked sights and crappy feeling action and trigger.
Still never had cycling issues or accuracy troubles.

I have however had bolt guns that gave me issues. Bolt binding or not picking up a round from the mag.

Get a lever gun and you will love it.
 
Reliability goes as follows Bolt -> pump -> lever -> semi. Pick your poison.

I would say :
Break action
Bolt
Lever
Pump
Semi
Just my take on it but I believe the reason you see levers chambered in heavier cal. Is the action is stronger . Perhaps I’m associating strength with reliability?
 
I would say :
Break action
Bolt
Lever
Pump
Semi
Just my take on it but I believe the reason you see levers chambered in heavier cal. Is the action is stronger . Perhaps I’m associating strength with reliability?

Heavier but lower pressure cartridges, so not stronger. Break-open single shots likewise might be reliable, but not designed for heavy cartridges unlike a falling block like a Ruger #1 or Browning 1885 which can confidently handle severe overpressure if needed. I'm using factory loads in my break-open .35 Whelen CVA Scout until I build up a bit more experience just to be on the safe side.

In the end it all boils down to design.

I've fired a BAR in .375 Taylor which would blow Marlin and Winchester lever guns to smithereens. And my own personal BAR has so far been the most reliable gun I've owned. Not the most accurate, it's an honest 1-to-1.5 MOA shooter, but the mag seats firmly, feeds reliably, cycles flawlessly with 7 factory loads and now 2 handloads, ejects with authority, and has gone a few shooting and hunting sessions without being cleaned (because it's a pain to clean).

In comparison, my Zastava bolt action has a number of minor problems (quality control, mostly), my Stevens bolt action doesn't eject very positively, my Enfield grouped like a shotgun pattern, my m700 needed a trigger and a new mag spring, etc.

I doubt all semi's can take the same punishment, maybe the Benelli Argo, but it's not something I'd try with an old Remington semi or pump.

I would probably rate them more like this:
Falling-block single shot
Bolt action
Positive lockup lever action and semi auto (BAR/BLR - multi-lug steel bolt head locking into steel barrel)
Lever action
Break-open single shot
Pump
 
Heavier but lower pressure cartridges, so not stronger. Break-open single shots likewise might be reliable, but not designed for heavy cartridges unlike a falling block like a Ruger #1 or Browning 1885 which can confidently handle severe overpressure if needed. I'm using factory loads in my break-open .35 Whelen CVA Scout until I build up a bit more experience just to be on the safe side.

In the end it all boils down to design.

I've fired a BAR in .375 Taylor which would blow Marlin and Winchester lever guns to smithereens. And my own personal BAR has so far been the most reliable gun I've owned. Not the most accurate, it's an honest 1-to-1.5 MOA shooter, but the mag seats firmly, feeds reliably, cycles flawlessly with 7 factory loads and now 2 handloads, ejects with authority, and has gone a few shooting and hunting sessions without being cleaned (because it's a pain to clean).

In comparison, my Zastava bolt action has a number of minor problems (quality control, mostly), my Stevens bolt action doesn't eject very positively, my Enfield grouped like a shotgun pattern, my m700 needed a trigger and a new mag spring, etc.

I doubt all semi's can take the same punishment, maybe the Benelli Argo, but it's not something I'd try with an old Remington semi or pump.

I would probably rate them more like this:
Falling-block single shot
Bolt action
Positive lockup lever action and semi auto (BAR/BLR - multi-lug steel bolt head locking into steel barrel)
Lever action
Break-open single shot
Pump

Agree if we’re talking Strength not reliability? Gotta be . A single shot anything with a person as the loader / ejector has got to be top .
 
Yes, but you won’t see troops going into battle choosing a lever over a semi. Never.

SCG

Are you looking for a hunting rifle? Or a battle rifle? Seriously in a shtf situation if you find your self in a spot where you are defending against a military group....you'll be dead before you even begin. Don't kid yourself into thinking you can with little to zero battle training that even with a belt fed mini gun you would have even the slightest chance of surviving.
Think of your rifle as a hunting rifle that will put meat on the table or possibly and I mean possibly used as a threat tool to keep what is yours from thieves...a good lever, or bolt action serves these purposes very well.
 
So trying to do a lot of research this is the problem that I have. I'm looking for a lever action, but I hear that they have a lot of problems because they have so many internal moving parts and so many screws, making them unreliable. I do not want a bolt action. So I guess my question is apart from a lever action what other semi-automatic is reliable? It seems everywhere I go somebody says don't buy one of those they have nothing but problems, or, the BLR is a good choice but they don't make them anymore.Can anybody help me decide whether lever actions are okay after all or should I go with a semi. BTW, looking for a 300 or 308.

After deer hunting since 1961 with mostly lever action rifles I would 100% recomend the Browning BLR as the overall best. Mine is a .243 Win.
and have killed everything I shot @ with it. Most of my shots are within 200 yds. as I live in the east.
 
the best advice since a while lol ...

Use what you've got...

90
 
Back
Top Bottom