wildey .45 or desert eagle .44?

JTF#

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 99.5%
217   1   0
Location
Ontario
since i cant post a poll i will just make a post.

what would you choose of these two guns? wildey is a .45 win-mag and the Desert eagle is a .44 mag.
(cost is not a factor.)





 
As a Man I would choose a revolver... :p

I owned a DE 44mag. Very accurate, little recoil but not very reliable :(
 
That would be difficult for me. I'd want both as one is a shooter and one is a collector.

Even if the Wildey is a collector, I would still want to shoot it and ammo availability is an issue, which has caused me to hesitate about pulling the trigger on the wildly before. but i suppose it is easy enough to reload with 45 acp dies if you can find a stock of brass.
 
I've shot both the DE and a Wildey in .475 Wildey mag. The Wildey was a turd. Machining was poor and just felt "off". Ammo in that caliber was a problem too. Handloads only. .45Win Mag might be different.

Auggie D.
 
No .45 Mag ammo. Seasonal only from Winchester. Rusty Wood says they have brass. $18 per 50. Lee makes dies, but I suspect you'd have to special order 'em. Redding wants $100US, Stateside. $168.95 US and special order only from RCBS.
A Desert Eagle is the biggest friggin' hand gun I've ever fired. Even though it comes nowhere near fitting my hand.
 
No .45 Mag ammo. Seasonal only from Winchester. Rusty Wood says they have brass. $18 per 50. Lee makes dies, but I suspect you'd have to special order 'em. Redding wants $100US, Stateside. $168.95 US and special order only from RCBS.
A Desert Eagle is the biggest friggin' hand gun I've ever fired. Even though it comes nowhere near fitting my hand.

45 acp dies work fine
 
I'm still not seeing any push for one or the other. its just I have both but I can only keep one or the other. the desert eagle is my fave gun of all time but the wildey is just so rare. ammo is not an issue actually you can just use .45 acp dies for the wildey you don't need the magnum ones. the only problem I see with ether pistol is that because the wildey is so rare getting any parts for it is near impossible. so like 15 years from now if something brakes the gun is pretty much deactivated. I had a missing extractor in it and one had to actually be custom made. but the DE parts you can get any place really. but at the same time I do very little pistol shooting so there shouldn't be much chance for something to brake.

as for shooing them. the DE has never given me problems. only with weak ass loads and reloading. but the wildey is some times pain to adjust the gas system since I only have a limited amount of brass. plus the slide stop works its way out after a few shots. basically both guns are pigs not glocks.

I will wait to hear from a few more people.
 
Have the DE (in 44 and 50AE) and aside from me finding a way to break the piston, it runs like a champ.

The Wildey would be one of those guns that's just so cool to have, but fear of breakage means I doubt that I'd take it out much.

Flip a coin?

(E) :cool:
 
Back
Top Bottom