Your advice on an used metal lathe

Finding a older South Bend 9 lathe would not be a bad option for getting into the new hobby of machining. These lathes are so common and good for their size that there is a pretty healthy owner's community and reproduction spares are quite commonly available as a result.

Myford shares a similarly enthusiastic community and there are a number of small suppliers for reproduction parts.

Plus once you have a bit more machining time under your belt the lathe itself can be used to make many repairs or replacements. And when you eventually add a milling machine to rest alongside the lathe there won't be much you can't replicate or repair in conjunction with the lathe.

The downside of buying used for your first lathe is that you first need to know what sort of wear is important and tolerable and how to measure it quickly while doing a "drop in for a look" sort of inspection. And that part is not easy to learn without some sort of lathe time under your belt.

Bed wear on a lathe is important. The bed will tend to wear more in the most frequently used area by small items of 4" or less length held in the chuck. This ties in with the idea that 95% or more of lathe jobs can be done on a smaller machine. So looking for bed "sag" due to wearing a hollow is a big thing.

If you bring along a good known to be straight fairly heavy 12" long ruler and a set of feeler gauges you can measure the wear on the prismatic and flat rails in that area. I'd say that if you can bridge the area and poke a shim of up to around .002 to .003 in there that's about the limit I'd want to see. If the gap accepts an .004 or greater then walk away. Almost any price at that point would not be worth it since as a beginner you would be trying to compensate for too much variation.

It's not just the resulting sway back over that area. It's also that the complementary hump in the carriage is going to be an issue too. Anything longer where you roll the carriage out of the dip means it will be sitting on the middle of the sag worn into the riding surfaces.

A good machinist can work around the issues that such a shape will cause. But as a beginner you'll have enough on your plate and don't need these sorts of complications. There's enough good lathes out there that it's better to pass up and move on.

For giggles I just checked my own lathe using the same method. I'm very happy to report that the visible wear on my prismatic way appears to be no more than visible. Using this same method I can't fit even a .0015" shim under the ruler at any point.
 
For what it's worth, there is a not bad looking Colchester Master 2500 on Crown Assets, out of Borden Ontario.

Listed as needing a new motor, which was likely in the cards anyways, as few folks that are not industrial, have 600 volt service.

It has a 3 and 4 jaw chucks, taper attachment, a few odds and sods for tailstock tooling, as well as the steady and follow rests (hard to find separate!).

I have a 3HP 220v 3Ph motor for mine, and two different VFD's to use. Was planning on replacing the coolant pump motor with a 110v single ph unit, when I get around to ...

This one is in nice looking shape, they didn't glop it all over with porch paint for a make-work project, and from the lack of wear on the dials of the speed selector, it sure doesn't look like it saw any hard use.

Read about the model on the www.lathes.co.uk site. Nice 13x40 or so machine. Probably gonna sell for a lot less than the same size new import!
 
I also have a Colchester 2500 and have it running on a 3hp 220 single phase.
The one on crown assets will be a great deal for someone.
 
I think I will give a try. I have room and 3 phases/600v in my shop. Thank for tip guys.

Take a look at the Sold Items listings, and you can get a decent idea of how the prices have been going. Bid according to your willingness to risk.
It is a sealed bid system, so it's not like a live auction where you get to see what the last guy was offering. Everyone just makes their best guess and fills out the number, at close, the guy that offered most gets it.

I have lost bids by as little as a couple dollars, have spoke to guys that have literally lost by pennies...
You don't usually get to find out what any of the other bids were. Maybe you were the only guy in the game, maybe everyone else knew something you did not, and they all bid what it was worth, instead of what you paid, or maybe, you decided you wanted it for yourself, and we're not buying for resale, so you could afford to pad your bid a little fatter than a dealer looking to buy it for inventory can... It's a guessing game.

If you can pick it up yourself, great. Lots of trucking outfits around though, dealing through a freight broker is pretty easy, and not terribly expensive. Eg: I bought a 4000 pound CNC mill, had it trucked from Bagotville Quebec, to Cold Lake Alberta, cost me just about $2K. I could have done quite a bit better had I a business account with the broker, but it was sure cheaper than a cross Canada truck trip, plus the time.

Oh yeah. Before you spend money on a replacement motor, do some careful troubleshooting and see if there is actually anything wrong with it, and check through the systems to see where the actual fault lies. I have bought stuff that was marked as being for parts only, when what it was, was essentially new, but sat in people's way for so long they got rid of it, and said it was for parts or salvage, because they thought that would stop folks from squabbling if they found faults once they got the stuff home. Bought what would have been 10 grand worth of diesel welder for under a thousand bucks on the floor at my house, including gas and ferry fees. Thing had 12 hours total run time, a new battery, and a full tank of fuel, too!
 
Last edited:
I think I will give a try. I have room and 3 phases/600v in my shop. Thank for tip guys.

You been holding out on us. 600 3phase in YOUR SHOP ! ? ! ? That's not the typical home gunsmith garage ! ! ! ! :d

If you were to buy something like that Colchester you would have a machine that you'll never outgrow. If you can go for it you will not ever regret it provided it doesn't have any skeletons in the tail stock cabinet.... :d
 
Yeah, I'll double down on my previous. Troubleshoot very carefully! It may be something cheap and simple, like a broken wire, bad bearings, or a switch or contacter that is the root cause. Or it may be all lies, because some fool who knows less than he has the authority to enforce, decided that the lathe was old, and he wanted a new one. It's not beyond considering, the guys may have actually pulled a wire or two loose, in order to justify getting a new toy. Though that isn't common, I have seen stuff purposely broken, so that workload would go away.

More than once, I have had to fend off new supervisors, who pointed at equipment without knowing a damn thing about it, asking "Do we use that? Do we need it? It takes up a lot of floor space!" Since I left the forces, I have actually seen a fair bit of the stuff that I had fought to keep around, go out through Crown Assets. Cheap, too!

It's depressing, just remembering going through that so many times. But the plus side is, there are some great deals to be had if you are willing to watch for the stuff, and take the occasional risk with money you can afford to tie up or maybe lose.

I have several machine tools, a car, an ATV, and some other misc. stuff that I have bought on there, and I have not figured I lost out yet. I tend to bid very low, unless I really want something, then I try to bid either just low, or fair prices. If it is close, AND I really want it, I will bid accordingly, as stuff that is close, costs me less to retrieve, eh.
 
Looks like a fair price.

Look at Grizzly/South Bend website, and you can find a pretty good quality Far East import copy of that for around $20k US.
 
I was a few hundreds dollars to low.

There will be others come along. Continue to keep an eye out, continue to educate yourself about the quality levels, the features, etc., and you will find a lathe that grabs your 'need'.

Problem with all those auctions is, you've got to have plan to get it home and that can get costly.

Grizz

Plan, and bid, accordingly. I drove from the Interior of BC to Victoria to pick up my latest welding machine. Wasn't a very exciting way to spend the day, sitting on the Ferry crossings, but they have wifi, and I had a couple good books on my ipad...
Gas money, meals, ferry fees, and I got a miller diesel welder with a TIG box and cables, etc., for just about $1K on my shop floor. I figure the time and risk was worth it! :) And a day away from the farm.

In reality, the shipping costs on that lathe will be on par with what you would pay to ship any other similar size object.

Like I related earlier, a 4000 pound milling machine, from Boondocks Quebec, Bagotville, to Cold Lake Alberta, also pretty much boondocks, was under $2K, and my total involvement was one phone call, with my Visa card in hand.
Had I a business account with the Freight Broker, it would have been considerably cheaper.
 
Back
Top Bottom