Well my experience with Shotguns is limited only to pumps and only Ithaca 37s, Remington 870s, Mossbergs, Mavericks, and Grizzlys.
Like the safety on Mossbergs, like the bottom extraction of Ithacas, Mavericks reminded me of a cheap Mossberg, Remington liked the quality, Grizzly liked the cost and machined receiver.
So after 30 years of using 12 gauge pumps what did I keep, the Grizzly tube fed(flame on).
Why, its tough as nails and never fails.
What did I do, full polish of all the moving parts, Hogue 12" stock, new sling, aluminum fore end.
I have lots of experiences with all kinds of Remmies and frankly I like the Grizzly more because of the 12.5" barrel option and cost.
So go to the range try a few out as what people post will be nothing more than biased opinions.......
I usually just use the ghost rings, put this Aimpoint for fun.
Randy