Cracks in my brand new Smith and Wesson 986

GundamZero

CGN frequent flyer
Rating - 99.5%
208   1   1
Location
Toronto
Well my Brand new 986 came in the mail today. I was very excited. The gun looked mint, until I looked at the crane of the revolver. There was a couple gouges and a hair line crack.

Now I am going to run this gun hard, should I be worried about the crack and return it or just keep it and shoot it. This is not going to be a safe queen.



 
Last edited:
You paid for PERFECTION....an that is NOT IT.

I'd be on the horn sending that piece of junk back instantly.
 
Egad! The last thing you want on any gun is a crack!

Whether wood or metal, what appears as a fine crack opens up in pulses as the gun vibrates during firing. They will *always* spread farther.

It's not a super load-bearing part when the cylinder is closed, but it does hold the mass of the cylinder and ammunition when open. If you ever let some goon try it out and he flips the gun closed with one hand, you may see it go flying. You're sure that is a crack? It's hard to photograph a hair-line, so some people might tell you it's just a scratch.

You bought it new; that defect would be un-acceptable on a used K Frame, let alone a new Performance Center! If it breaks later it's not just a drop-in replacement. The crane is fitted to the cylinder and frame, among other things setting the gap at the forcing cone. On a tuned PC revolver that gap is minimal, and the whole works turn like silk. Aside from getting what you paid for, you should fix it now while you know the factory has the parts and a competent repair centre. While not very likely, if you use it a bit then put it in the back of your safe and it breaks in a few years, they might start telling you ‘Oh those models are hard to service now.’

Marks on the frame seem to be from overly enthusiastic stamping of that deep, deep ‘986.’ Something I'd live with if it were the only problem.

[EDIT] You're the one with the gun in hand; you say it's a hair-line crack that's what it is, but be certain. (Told ya it's hard to photograph cracks.)
 
Looks like tool marks when the 986 was stamped. You will give her some nasty scratches as you use it. Unless you will keep her as a safe queen, I do not see any safety concern. But for the more meticulous shooter, every scratch from a brand new firearm counts.
 
Whether it is a structural issue or not (and I'm pretty sure it's not) I must say I'd be pretty disappointed with that level of finish/workmanship on a gun that lists well over $1,000. I think I'd email the photos to S&W and see what they say.

Guess I'll stick to Smiths from before 1960. ;)
 
My guess, not cracks but probably the stamp machine left some marks.
Nevertheles, there is marks that shouldn't be there.
If I bought it from a lgs....back it goes pronto.
But online, you have to ask yourself if it's worth fronting shipping costs again?

After ship and taxes...$1400 +.....I don't expect this from any manufacturer.
 
It cracks me up you guy care about a tiny seem and not the aweful electric pencilled number :p

S&W will laugh you off, if you complain about a common seem from the manufacturering process
 
It cracks me up you guy care about a tiny seem and not the aweful electric pencilled number :p

S&W will laugh you off, if you complain about a common seem from the manufacturering process

Yeah, what is that in the top right of the photos? Looks like Hell....surely it didn't come from the factory like that? :confused:
 
Could be also be casting marks. Gone are the days where forging is the way to go. Majority of firearms are now reliant to casting with that goes with a definitely improved manufacturing process and better metallurgy.
 
I like cracks...





but not necessarily on guns.

Your gun is fine, no cracks at all, if you can't live with it send it back.
 
Run a dye check if you want to be sure. Kits should be available at Acklands or an experienced rep can tell you where to get one. If it's not a crack you may have an uphill climb to get S&W to fess up and that begs the question how much is your time and frustration worth?
 
Sorry to say don't worry about it and just go use it. It is a sign of the times and there is nothing we can do about it. It will get far worse before it gets better.

Graydog
 
Back
Top Bottom