Is it me or is the bullet on the bottom a smaller diameter ? holey cow . if I'm correct that looks like old stock because of the box . in that case you may have no recourse . I'd still forward a photo of that to Federal's quality control department . and may I ask why did you pull those ? bad accuracy ? or did the ammo get damp and you were going to reload them ? they look like some old style of ballistic tip ammo . tell me if I'm correct . and yes I would forward some photos to Federal . maybe they will mail you a coupon for some ammo .