@ Silverado. You've a keen eye! Those 2 primers are seated differently, which I initially thought primer depth was a possible cause.
I held those 2 up to talk to that idea, that was Feb 15th. But then after the range session Feb 20, I realized the primers weren't the problem and changed the original comments I was going to throw out about primer depth.
So I talked at length with the guys where I bought the rifle and discussed several options. If worst came to worst, they would exchange that rifle for me and give me a brand new rifle. But I don't want to go there, and it shouldn't require that anyway.
There's a shop in St. Albert that does Browning/Winchester warranty sork and I'm taking the rifle there next Wed to get it looked at by their techs. I'm sure they will be able to resolve the issue.