I dont really want to get anybody too frazzeled here, and, contrary to the manner in which I've seen many other theads degrade, I'd like to stay away from all the poo-flinging and bickering associated with those who love it and those who hate it. (ie: those think the practise is stupid, moronic, or bad technique, or just not their cup of tea).
Those who dont like the idea of it - need to make a distinction between responsible firearms owners and drunken douchebags shooting gas cans on YouTube.
Its subjective. Like a few of you, I am also of the belief such shotguns would not necessairily make you a better, more accurate, or faster shooter. But, like
cyclone and
H Wally, I think it would be interesting to try out. (worth the the 200-300 for an old beater anyways)
Cowboy action guys do it all the time.
Fact of the matter is, the practise is perfectly legal, as are the firearms that can perform in such a manner. Thus, discussing it shouldnt be much of an issue. Unless I missed the newsletter where we only talk about bolt actions and SxS's on CGN.
Most of these shotguns are many decades old. Its nothing new, and shouldnt be cause for anyone to get bent out of shape.
Lets try and keep it objective.
So... List wise...
Win 1897
Win Mod 12/1912
Ithaca Mod 37 (up to a certain year?)
Win 1300 (possibly?)
Maybe you fellas with some old pumps can do some dry runs on them and let us know?