I know about taking a gun to the US, but have to agree with Ice on this 1. If it was ANY other caliber and NOT a rifle that may have been made in the US, no problem. Given the "terminal analitis" that some of the border guys on either side seem to have, I agree it is just not worth the risk.
I have had temporary Cdn export permits as well as Form 6s challenged at the border, and despite my being legal and correct still had to go back to the border to collect my kit once the determination was handed down.
Technically you are correct, there SHOULD NOT be an issue, however......
Having you gun "detained" while you try to prove that the rifle was legally exported from the before the export restriction, can be difficult. It is not like the CFC is going to be of any assistance by saying, "Yes this rifle was registed in 2000 so must have been here before the export ban"
Sometimes even when 1 is right, it is not worth swimming upstream
Rick,
If you fill out declaration papers at Canada Customs and take your copy of this document along with your Form 6 copy, and your CFC registration certificate, then there seldom are any issues. The Canada Customs declaration does carry some weight with the US border people. Even if it's not required to enter the US, it's always a great thing to have to prove legal ownership before entering the US.
Most US border agents just confirm the pertinent information and serial numbers off the Form 6 and you're good to go. That's if they even bother to ask for it.
Please, correct me if I'm wrong, but seeing how CFC won't register firearms that don't have the appropriate import documentation from the host country, then how could anyone be anything other than legal under the circumstances?
Besides, if you're that worried about it, then bring a copy of your orginal bill of sale or supporting import/export documentation if you've imported it yourself. Seeing how everything is dated, you're good to go.
As I'm sure you know, BATF doesn't regard firearms listed on Form 6A's to be considered as "importations" because they are only temporarily in country.
I've been held up for hours at the border before as well. No big deal as I've always had my s**t together. As anyone who has ever went through this process before can relate to, if your paperwork is clear, concise, and laid out logically in front of the agent and you're not fumbling or rummaging around for things, then you don't draw undue attention to yourself. Organization is definitely the key to making sure things go smoothly and efficiently. For those who have never gone accross border before, I can't stress that enough.
Once you've done it a few times, it's a minor inconvenience at best.
If you're not willing to "swim upstream" every once in a while, then you're giving up way too easily.