Nothing but positive experiences myself with Epps. I've spent many times there tire-kicking, was humoured respectfully every time, and have purchased 2 guns from them since. Very pleased with them, will definitely return there when they have what I want. Prices seem reasonable to me also, definitely not over-priced on anything that I've shopped for.
I can see how I would be frustrated discovering that a firearm I purchased was faulty months down the line, but you have to look at it from their perspective. Someone buys a used firearm, shoots 1,000's of rounds from it over the course of 3 months and then something goes wrong, would the retailer be expected to cover any damage at that point? How would you prove where the fault lies? A line has to be drawn somewhere for everyone, and there will always be that 1% of cases that will deservedly not agree with it and will suffer through no fault of their own such mishaps, which is unfortunate. But it's business, and you can't please everyone every time. The internet just happens to give more voice to the whiners, as is exemplified by this thread.
That being said, I wouldn't buy a new let alone used firearm during a time of year that I couldn't go out and shoot it as soon as practically possible to make sure I was pleased with it, and to do so seems irresponsible. Would you buy a snowblower from Canadian Tire in the spring and not start it until the winter knowing their return policy? How about a used one somewhere? It seems to me that extraordinary extensions of courtesy are being expected from this retailer, or at the least this type of retailer.
I'll tell you that the hundreds of customers that go through that store every day walk out a hell of a lot more pleased with service then the thousands walking out of Bass Pro or any big retailer. I know I won't shop at my local gunsmith/firearms dealer, and Epps is a 2 1/2 hour drive for me. Oh, and the service on the phone does suck, I would much rather walk in.
canadaman30, the experience you described is bulls**t, and I am shocked to hear that of them. I hope for their sake there was more to the story then that, but that is definitely something that I would take seriously. Sorry to hear that...
Holding of merchandise update seems well justified Harrier, good on you guys, though the number thing would be welcomed for sure. I think OP is over-reacting just a little bit over this...