And controlled round feeding is only important to those who are trying to feed a round upside down with a charging grizzly while lying on your back.... I will take a glass smooth bolt anytime for range work, deer, elk or moose hunting, and for varmints over a CRF.... I had 6 of them..... 3 Mausers and 2 Winchesters and 1 Kimber.
there are more benefits to CRF than being reliable when upside-down and being charged by a grizzly - although that surely cant hurt, can it?
its actually quite hard to make a push-feed Remington NOT chamber a round while jostling the rifle or holding it at an angle or even upside down.. however this is not the main disadvantage of a push feed,
this is:
if you short-stroke a push feed you can end up with a partially chambered round that is not ejected since the extractor never had a chance to snap over the rim of the cartridge. if you try to chamber another round youll end up with a jam (or worse i suppose, on the miniscule chance that the tip of the second round happens to slam into the primer of the first). yes, its a noob-assed thing to do but in a panicked situation (or even typical 'buck fever') many otherwise experienced people may actually short-stroke a bolt-action... which could cost them their game or their life.
this is why almost all dangerous game rifles that
arent doubles are CRFs.
also, since its a fixed ejector your cases will be damaged less: there is no spring-loaded ejector forcing the case diagonally against the chamber on unloading, and you can vary the ejection of spent cases from 2 benches down to softly rolling them into your hand based on how forcefully you work the bolt.
and id rather have a bigass non-rotating claw extractor. the likelihood of even a Remington extractor failing is
very low, but still - a Mauser style extractor is just somehow comforting to have. just
one failure is enough to seriously ruin your day.
while i totally agree with you that the benefits of CRF are unlikely to make much of a difference in the average hunter's lifetime, seeing as both rifles cost roughly the same id rather have a CRF rifle and an overengineered extractor on the off chance that a situation might arise where they do.