Best non-res SHTF gun?

I guess it depends on what kind of SHTF.

Riots: Shotgun
Country being invaded: some sort of military style rifle
Loss of infrastructure: handgun (for the city)
Zombies: anything and everything

If someone were concerned about being prepared for SHTF I'd say just get an SKS and a crate or two of ammo and call 'er done.
 
"Oh crap, s**t is hitting the fan. I guess I can only use my non-restricted compliant rifle to fend off chaos" ;)

It's been mentioned a few times in the thread. SHTF doesn't necessarily mean zombies/alien invasion/ninjas taking over. What if the government decided to come and raid all the firearm owners? They wouldn't know what you have.

That's a real SHTF scenario.
 
This may sound a little weak but I would grab a light weight 22lr. And escape into the woods... Why a 22? I can carry thousands of rnds on me.

I will be eating what I catch and there is a lot more small game running around then large.

Also, you shoot something enough with a 22 and it should go down.

Good survival gun and will be light to carry.
 
This may sound a little weak but I would grab a light weight 22lr. And escape into the woods... Why a 22? I can carry thousands of rnds on me.

I will be eating what I catch and there is a lot more small game running around then large.

Also, you shoot something enough with a 22 and it should go down.

Good survival gun and will be light to carry.

Krinker plinker with folding stock and a red dot with a drum mag FTW!!!
 
.22's probably kill more game than any other caliber in the world.

There's nothing wrong with a .22's abiltiy to kill, so long as shot placement is good/perfect.

I've fired .22's out to 400 yards, and am comfortable with my ability to hit rapidly (0.22 second measured split time on an IPSC timer)

Is a .22 ideal? Probably not, but it's a good, readily available, non restricted option.

I personally would not feel under-armed with a magazine fed, semi-auto .22 in my hand.

NS
 
In keeping with the original question that was posed back in 2007 on this thread, I would choose a rifle that:
- Used stripper clips and maybe a magazine as well.
- Had solid iron sights.
- Was easy to train friends and family on how to use.
- Easy to clean.
- Inexpensive enough to own more than one (spare parts).
- Could be dragged through the mud and still go bang.

Yes the mighty SKS is my choice. Non-corrosive ammo is a no brainer here as well.

There are many scenarios that have been pointed out here like bugging in, bugging out, alone or with family, temporary SHTF that may take weeks or months to fix, or the worst scenario where it may take a generation or two to get back to some sense of normality. In absolutely all cases, there is one thing that has been occasionally stated on this thread that as a bit of an accuracy nut I could not agree more with, and that is……… shot placement. If you can’t send a well-placed warning shot down range or hit the heart of your family dinner on the run, the whole concept of a great SHTF weapon (gun, bow, slingshot) is worthless. I mentioned warning shot as I believe in a real SHTF scenario, a near miss is all that will be required to make your point. Just go hide and protect the ones you love at all costs and hope you never have to take another human’s life in doing so.

As a side note, I am a newbie to CGN and have enjoyed this thread to no end. I am off work sick today and have made my way through it from beginning to end (excellent time waster). When I get back to Canada, I really want to try the venerable .223 and am now trying to decide whether to go with the Swiss Arms PE90, Benneli MR1, Tavor, or try the AR platform. Naturally I will go to the appropriate thread for those opinions but there were some great comments here on those particular rifles.
 
What are ppl's thoughts on the Su-16f?

Chambered in 223 - so its a good round. Polymer stock so nice and durable. Can carry 3x10 rnd magazines right on the gun. And the whole thing folds in half for easy carry!

I think I'd like to get one of these someday.
 
What are ppl's thoughts on the Su-16f?

Chambered in 223 - so its a good round. Polymer stock so nice and durable. Can carry 3x10 rnd magazines right on the gun. And the whole thing folds in half for easy carry!

I think I'd like to get one of these someday.

I owned one so here are my thoughts. This was my first semi gun so take it with a grain of salt:

PROS
-- I like the concept of the gun. It does fold nice in original configuration. I like idea of the American Su-16A better but really how often would you need to shoot with the stock folded (the F does not shoot with the stock folded).
-- very light gun. So if SHTF means lots of hiking, then that's great
-- you can replace the crappy stock mags with LAR 10 rounders (and then in the event of SHTF you just get whatever capacity ones you want).
-- non-restricted (but that means nothing in real SHTF scenario). But I guess in the lead up to it you can get plenty of "practice" in and not restricted to a range
-- I never really felt I had to clean it between shooting (but I did anyway). It shot very clean.
-- chrome lined barrel
-- field strip is fairly simple once you do it a couple times.
-- can replace the stock with AR pistol grip and other stock
-- I felt I could shoot several 10 round mags worth rapidfire and it felt fine. In a pinch yes it could get you out of a bind. It never felt so hot I had to stop.
-- 'bipod' that comes out of the original foregrip. I guess it's better than nothing but I also listed it as a con
-- I like the stock trigger.
-- comes with top rail
-- Kel-Tec service is very good I thought. Phone call, email had good responses and also the distributor Vault was very good to deal with. Twice Kel-Tec mailed me out parts at their cost. So get any issues worked out before SHTF!
-- bolt hold open on empty is nice

CONS
-- the original bipod /foregrip is a pure gimmick. It's dumb But I guess in a pinch...
-- if you don't like the original stock, none of the replacements will fold completely. The AR/stock addition only folds the gun into an "L", which is kind of awkward.
-- It is finicky with ammo. It did not like Chinese surplus .223 but it did fine with American Eagle.
-- some don't like the plastic top rail. I had no problem with it.
-- you need to replace the original foregrip in order to install a lower rail. Unless you elect to drill a rail into the plastic of the original foregrip.
-- not much in the way of accessories that don't require some bubba work. The good stuff is not shipped to Canada unfortunately.
-- the stock magazines totally blow. It's the worst toy plastic. One broke on me for no apparent reason. And those are the ones that fit into the original stock for easy carrying.
-- I don't think the foregrip or stock would stand up to battling zombies. It is not the same zytel as the receiver. I would not use it to mash anything.
-- *the receiver of some units broke and so did mine after maybe 2000 rounds. The distributor assured me that it was just some dozen or so in a particular run and replaced the entire package. Up until then I would have said the zytel was solid and I didn't feel it was flimsy. I have since traded it to someone who liked the pros over the cons.
-- AR replacement stock does not use a buffer. But never felt it needed it. It's .223. Not much recoil or rise.
-- barrel is thin so maybe rapidfire might affect accuracy. I don't know, I'm not an expert on that.

In sum. It's no battle rifle but it's good backpacker that can fire a military round decently. It's cheap and you can buy one as a backup even and not feel like it's much extra weight. Make sure you have a 'good' one before the zombies rise.
 
I owned one so here are my thoughts. This was my first semi gun so take it with a grain of salt:

PROS
-- I like the concept of the gun. It does fold nice in original configuration. I like idea of the American Su-16A better but really how often would you need to shoot with the stock folded (the F does not shoot with the stock folded).
-- very light gun. So if SHTF means lots of hiking, then that's great
-- you can replace the crappy stock mags with LAR 10 rounders (and then in the event of SHTF you just get whatever capacity ones you want).
-- non-restricted (but that means nothing in real SHTF scenario). But I guess in the lead up to it you can get plenty of "practice" in and not restricted to a range
-- I never really felt I had to clean it between shooting (but I did anyway). It shot very clean.
-- chrome lined barrel
-- field strip is fairly simple once you do it a couple times.
-- can replace the stock with AR pistol grip and other stock
-- I felt I could shoot several 10 round mags worth rapidfire and it felt fine. In a pinch yes it could get you out of a bind. It never felt so hot I had to stop.
-- 'bipod' that comes out of the original foregrip. I guess it's better than nothing but I also listed it as a con
-- I like the stock trigger.
-- comes with top rail
-- Kel-Tec service is very good I thought. Phone call, email had good responses and also the distributor Vault was very good to deal with. Twice Kel-Tec mailed me out parts at their cost. So get any issues worked out before SHTF!
-- bolt hold open on empty is nice

CONS
-- the original bipod /foregrip is a pure gimmick. It's dumb But I guess in a pinch...
-- if you don't like the original stock, none of the replacements will fold completely. The AR/stock addition only folds the gun into an "L", which is kind of awkward.
-- It is finicky with ammo. It did not like Chinese surplus .223 but it did fine with American Eagle.
-- some don't like the plastic top rail. I had no problem with it.
-- you need to replace the original foregrip in order to install a lower rail. Unless you elect to drill a rail into the plastic of the original foregrip.
-- not much in the way of accessories that don't require some bubba work. The good stuff is not shipped to Canada unfortunately.
-- the stock magazines totally blow. It's the worst toy plastic. One broke on me for no apparent reason. And those are the ones that fit into the original stock for easy carrying.
-- I don't think the foregrip or stock would stand up to battling zombies. It is not the same zytel as the receiver. I would not use it to mash anything.
-- *the receiver of some units broke and so did mine after maybe 2000 rounds. The distributor assured me that it was just some dozen or so in a particular run and replaced the entire package. Up until then I would have said the zytel was solid and I didn't feel it was flimsy. I have since traded it to someone who liked the pros over the cons.
-- AR replacement stock does not use a buffer. But never felt it needed it. It's .223. Not much recoil or rise.
-- barrel is thin so maybe rapidfire might affect accuracy. I don't know, I'm not an expert on that.

In sum. It's no battle rifle but it's good backpacker that can fire a military round decently. It's cheap and you can buy one as a backup even and not feel like it's much extra weight. Make sure you have a 'good' one before the zombies rise.

Wow! I did not expect such an in-depth reply! Thank you very much Silveragent.
 
Shtf gun, non-res?

Big stuff: Lee Enfield - never fail, stop anything, common caliber, plenty of parts.

Little stuff: Ruger 10/22 - the game getter. Carry a years worth of ammo in your shirt pocket.

Keep the house safe: 12ga. Remington 870 my personal choice.
 
...
Keep the house safe: 12ga. Remington 870 my personal choice.
Once I was in a fun house shooting range and was doing a clearance drill with my shotie and the butt stock pushed my ear muffs off my ear's when I did the lean threw a door way drill. Damm...
Couldn't hear for like 2 minutes later.
 
Once I was in a fun house shooting range and was doing a clearance drill with my shotie and the butt stock pushed my ear muffs off my ear's when I did the lean threw a door way drill. Damm...
Couldn't hear for like 2 minutes later.

Try a flash bang at your feet in a narrow hall way....I swear to god I couldn't hear worth #### for a week. :D
 
-- AR replacement stock does not use a buffer. But never felt it needed it. It's .223. Not much recoil or rise.

Good reply, just had to point this out though...

The buffer on an AR has very little to do with recoil - yes the added mass reduces felt recoil to some extent. However, the mass of the buffer reduces the cyclic rate of the firearm. This is the purpose, not recoil reduction.

Like I said though, good reply and interesting to hear first hand experience with the SU-16... the cracking receiver BS has made me hesitant/unlikely to purchase one...


Personally, I'm saving my pennies for a XCR-L or M, just wish I had some pennies....

Matt
 
FN FS2000. Excellent trigger, great ergonomics, deadly accurate. Mostly polymer which is impervious to the elements (including a gasket in the mag well). Also ejects out the front which is handy when you need to shoot out of a moving vehicle... (I kid, I kid... ;) ).

It's always better to have the option just in case right! ;-)
 
Put lots of thought into this over the years and have owned AKs, SKSs, M1s, M305s, Mini 14s, ARs and it came down to this for me.

Really what distance are you going to be doing the engaging at what can you carry? Second what is going to be the most common ammo type? To me it will be .22, .223, and 12 gauge ammo.

Unrestricted guns mean nothing to me just like the 10 round debate. If things fall apart you bet all the pinned mags are going to be unpinned quickly!!!

So what have I ended up with?

A short CAR15 with lots of mags and .223 ammo, a CMMG .22 rimfire drop in conversion kit, lots of .22 rimfire, and a short 12 gauge. I can carry lots of .223 and the 26 round .22 rimfire conversion mags provide the rimfire quiet option in a .223 platform.

Randy
 
Back
Top Bottom