Elk slaughter in Manitoba

Ots said:
Can a sustenance hunter in Manitoba sell the meat?
Click to expand...

Not legally.

rubberdown said:
45ACPKING, if someone (like me) is a racist because we simply want equality, then I guess I'm guilty as charged. I'm racist because I dont think ANYONE should wear a hat or turban or anything on their head inside a Canadian Legion, I'm racist because I dont think ANY religious belief should be exempt and their parishioners be allowed to carry a large knife to school, I'm racist because I dont think anyone should be allowed to cover their face completely when in general public, this is Canada, NOT the middle east. I'm racist because my kid no longer hears the national anthem in school every morning, or the lords prayer. I'm racist because I can only "apply" to harvest certain big game animals with a very slim chance of getting a tag and Natives seem to have almost no limitations on what they can harvest. I hate a lotof things that happen in my country, I think a lot of things are unfair. So you need to blame Betty and Paul (my parents) for this because I was raised with 2 sisters and everything had to be fair or it was all out war in our house hold LOL.

If the hunters that took those 12 elk didnt break any laws (your non existent laws), then so be it, if they went back the next day and did it again, and the next day and the next day, then my complaint about being fair turns into a complaint about stripping the land of whats left. You cant hate or dislike someones opinions or their person simply because they want to be treated the same. With the benifits your people are given from the Canadian Government, I dont understand why there arent more native doctors, lawyers, engineers, whatever, Education is something that is given to you is it not? I will be lucky if I can send my kid to a local college and she will have to get a part time job during her studies just to help pay her tuition....do you see WHY people want some sort of balance here, some sort of equality? Try looking at both sides of the coin, not just the dark side from hundreds of years ago.
Click to expand...

Great post, my sentiments exactly.
 
rubberdown said:
45ACPKING, if someone (like me) is a racist because we simply want equality, then I guess I'm guilty as charged. I'm racist because I dont think ANYONE should wear a hat or turban or anything on their head inside a Canadian Legion, I'm racist because I dont think ANY religious belief should be exempt and their parishioners be allowed to carry a large knife to school, I'm racist because I dont think anyone should be allowed to cover their face completely when in general public, this is Canada, NOT the middle east. I'm racist because my kid no longer hears the national anthem in school every morning, or the lords prayer. I'm racist because I can only "apply" to harvest certain big game animals with a very slim chance of getting a tag and Natives seem to have almost no limitations on what they can harvest. I hate a lotof things that happen in my country, I think a lot of things are unfair. So you need to blame Betty and Paul (my parents) for this because I was raised with 2 sisters and everything had to be fair or it was all out war in our house hold LOL
If the hunters that took those 12 elk didnt break any laws (your non existent laws), then so be it, if they went back the next day and did it again, and the next day and the next day, then my complaint about being fair turns into a complaint about stripping the land of whats left. You cant hate or dislike someones opinions or their person simply because they want to be treated the same. With the benifits your people are given from the Canadian Government, I dont understand why there arent more native doctors, lawyers, engineers, whatever, Education is something that is given to you is it not? I will be lucky if I can send my kid to a local college and she will have to get a part time job during her studies just to help pay her tuition....do you see WHY people want some sort of balance here, some sort of equality? Try looking at both sides of the coin, not just the dark side from hundreds of years ago.
Click to expand...
Could we possibly get this put up as a "sticky" please.
 
rubberdown said:
45ACPKING, if someone (like me) is a racist because we simply want equality, then I guess I'm guilty as charged. I'm racist because I dont think ANYONE should wear a hat or turban or anything on their head inside a Canadian Legion, I'm racist because I dont think ANY religious belief should be exempt and their parishioners be allowed to carry a large knife to school, I'm racist because I dont think anyone should be allowed to cover their face completely when in general public, this is Canada, NOT the middle east. I'm racist because my kid no longer hears the national anthem in school every morning, or the lords prayer. I'm racist because I can only "apply" to harvest certain big game animals with a very slim chance of getting a tag and Natives seem to have almost no limitations on what they can harvest. I hate a lotof things that happen in my country, I think a lot of things are unfair. So you need to blame Betty and Paul (my parents) for this because I was raised with 2 sisters and everything had to be fair or it was all out war in our house hold LOL.

If the hunters that took those 12 elk didnt break any laws (your non existent laws), then so be it, if they went back the next day and did it again, and the next day and the next day, then my complaint about being fair turns into a complaint about stripping the land of whats left. You cant hate or dislike someones opinions or their person simply because they want to be treated the same. With the benifits your people are given from the Canadian Government, I dont understand why there arent more native doctors, lawyers, engineers, whatever, Education is something that is given to you is it not? I will be lucky if I can send my kid to a local college and she will have to get a part time job during her studies just to help pay her tuition....do you see WHY people want some sort of balance here, some sort of equality? Try looking at both sides of the coin, not just the dark side from hundreds of years ago.
Click to expand...


I'd vote for yeah
 
I'm not a hater but this above the law has to stop. They are regular people just like the rest of us, get with the times and grow up. I agree with NBK16 how would a white man be treated if he had done this with a group of hunting guys?
 
Alright enough with the racist cards and what not. Lets not beat around the bush anymore:
Send this to the gov`t: If there is enough Elk where the natives can take 12 at a time....they shouldn`t need the hand outs any more. They must be thriving with this "over populated" Elk community.
Am I wrong or what???????
 
I hope everyone who goes to the boat show this weekend in Winnipeg stopes and speaks to the Manitoba Wildlife Federation and Manitoba Concervation.
 
rubberdown said:
45ACPKING, if someone (like me) is a racist because we simply want equality, then I guess I'm guilty as charged. I'm racist because I dont think ANYONE should wear a hat or turban or anything on their head inside a Canadian Legion, I'm racist because I dont think ANY religious belief should be exempt and their parishioners be allowed to carry a large knife to school, I'm racist because I dont think anyone should be allowed to cover their face completely when in general public, this is Canada, NOT the middle east. I'm racist because my kid no longer hears the national anthem in school every morning, or the lords prayer. I'm racist because I can only "apply" to harvest certain big game animals with a very slim chance of getting a tag and Natives seem to have almost no limitations on what they can harvest. I hate a lotof things that happen in my country, I think a lot of things are unfair. So you need to blame Betty and Paul (my parents) for this because I was raised with 2 sisters and everything had to be fair or it was all out war in our house hold LOL.

If the hunters that took those 12 elk didnt break any laws (your non existent laws), then so be it, if they went back the next day and did it again, and the next day and the next day, then my complaint about being fair turns into a complaint about stripping the land of whats left. You cant hate or dislike someones opinions or their person simply because they want to be treated the same. With the benifits your people are given from the Canadian Government, I dont understand why there arent more native doctors, lawyers, engineers, whatever, Education is something that is given to you is it not? I will be lucky if I can send my kid to a local college and she will have to get a part time job during her studies just to help pay her tuition....do you see WHY people want some sort of balance here, some sort of equality? Try looking at both sides of the coin, not just the dark side from hundreds of years ago.
Click to expand...

wow,great quote...i am anxious to see someone try to argue against this
 
you can see that even the mods are getting fed up with this bs......this thread would have been shut down immediately a couple of years ago
 
Ethical behaviour is doing the right thing when no one else is watching- even when doing the wrong thing is legal. - Aldo Leopold.

I'd like to hear a sound, defensible argument to the effect that this harvest of elk was ethical.


Stef
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom