Well fellers, just for starters, I think the Ruger Blackhawk and Super Black Hawk series is superior in every way, to a first generation Colt SAA.
So much was said about S&W, without mentioning the various ownership status, accompanied by a very wide range of quality in them, over the years. S&W made great guns until a bit after the Model 29, 44 magnums came out with 6.5 inch barrels.
Then, some ownership changes, different places of manufacture and a decided change in quality. At least some of the 29s, some of those with six inch barrels, were very close to junk. Don't try to explain them to me, I have owned the K22, the 357 before it had a model number and just had "357 MAGNUM," rolled onto it and a good 6.5 inch 44.
Then I had the cheap built S&W 44 magnum with the 6 inch barrel. It had the poorest, cheapest made innards in it of any revolver I have ever seen. It made the working parts of an Iver Johnston look splendid!
While the old S&W revolvers looked, shot and were built great, I really think the best all around revolver I ever had was a 357 Rugrer Security Six.