The EE is a platform to sell firearms for firearms enthusiasts... I assume that is all of us... ergo it is a GOOD thing. As far as quality and "surprises" go, if you can read and comprehend and then ask the right questions, the risks are very low, I would trust business this way over an Amazon description on a new product. How many sell? 100% of what I have listed has sold, and I have likely bought more than my share. Remember, gun nutters are constantly trying new (to them) stuff... new platforms, new cartridges, new calibers we trade and sell back and forth. Many times, I have sold a rifle to some fine CGNer only to buy it back from them sometime later. I remember one rifle that I sold and then bought back, and then sold again and bought back again! I tend to not be terribly interested in firearms that can be purchased by anyone walking into their local gunshop. I prefer rarer, no longer in production pieces, and unique pieces, either for the platform or the cartridge... you can't get that from Cabelas. All-in-all, the EE is a great place to shop and I have met some fine, trustworthy gun enthusiasts and quality outdoorsmen through trading there. I can name many off the top of my head, folks that are fair and reasonable and honest, that I have done multiple deals with over the years.