CLP a very poor lubricant ?
Doubt it - its use by the military belies that assumption. The U.S. military extensively tested many types of goo - CLP came out on top. (1)
As a matter of fact - Break Free CLP (a thicker version once sold as stainless CLP) is used in Vulcan mini-guns.
It was the only lube that kept the carbon in suspension (blows out of the ejection ports more effectively) and prevent it from gumming up the works. (2)
CLP stands for cleaner lubricant preservative.
Motor oil may have more lubricity but I doubt it has the cleaning quality of CLP. Also, the teflon like stuff in CLP remains in the metal when the gun is dry, (just like seasoning a cast iron fry pan) increasing lubricity when the oil has dried up, congealed, run off or evaporated. (3)
Having said all that -- for civvie use - ANYTHING (motor oil, soap, neats foot oil, vagisil, walrus blubber, smegma etc. will do just fine.)