If a guy asks where he can find a good steakhouse, do you tell him he's wrong and should be looking for sushi instead? He wants a mini.
Just for the record, I haven't been without at least one mini for 35 years or so, and after an unrestricted Colt AR, an AR180, and a couple of Swiss Arms, the only semiauto .223 I have now is a mini. The new ones are the best shooters of the bunch, easily as accurate as any other sub-$3000 .223 NR semi's out there . Good luck, and enjoy!
Oh, and another place to contact for one is Wiliams' Arms in Port Perry...very trustworthy guys!

Thanks for your point of view cr5. I know Mini's seem to be a controversial topic here.
For me, I was just looking for a reliable .223 semi auto that is non-restricted. I know at the end of the day I may spend as much as I would if I had just purchased an AR-15 but I wanted to be able to take it into the bush if I wanted. From what I hear, the new Mini's with the tapered barrels are much better in the accuracy department and I can always get a har-bar stabilizer if needed.
I've looked at some other alternatives but the prices are a bit out of my range:
Swiss arms is up at $3000+
XCR is $2000+
not fond of the look of the Benelli MR-1 or the HK SL-8
anything obvious I missed?
Thanks for your point of view cr5. I know Mini's seem to be a controversial topic here.
For me, I was just looking for a reliable .223 semi auto that is non-restricted. I know at the end of the day I may spend as much as I would if I had just purchased an AR-15 but I wanted to be able to take it into the bush if I wanted. From what I hear, the new Mini's with the tapered barrels are much better in the accuracy department and I can always get a har-bar stabilizer if needed.
I've looked at some other alternatives but the prices are a bit out of my range:
Swiss arms is up at $3000+
XCR is $2000+
not fond of the look of the Benelli MR-1 or the HK SL-8
anything obvious I missed?
Thanks for all your opinions guys, I'm open to any advice you have to give.
Dmitri, I've actually been struggling between the mini 14 and the SU-16. I was originally attracted to the Mini 14 because of it's rock solid reliability and the fact that I could correct the accuracy issue with a stabilizer. I also really like the Pro-mag archangel stock.
I like the SU-16's ability to take AR mags but I have heard mixed reviews about the quality and reliability. Any truth in that?
Also, how easy is it to customize the SU-16? I know it's kinda vain but I want to "tacti-cool" up this rifle. I haven't seen many options for the foregrip without some modifications needed and as you can tell by my status over there (<--)..i'm still a newbie!
Maybe I should start another thread but...how do people feel about the Mini 14 vs. the SU 16?
No offence to anyone that has one and maybe yours is better than the one I had but why would you want one of those?
They are way more money than they are worth in my opinion.
I had an older one with 1:7 twist barrel and while it was very reliable it was terrible in the accuracy department. I think it was about 4 inch groups at 100 yards on a good day. I just made a lot of noise with it and had to appologise to everyone sitting to my right at the range about the brass flying 30 feet over and hitting people.
Save your money for a decent rifle. You will end up spending the money you saved trying to put an aftermarket stock on it and buying expensive mags trying to make it a black rifle and will eventually sell it and buy a real black rifle anyway.
YMMV
Let me see...... One of the shortest rifles (18.5" barrel) Non restricted box magazine fed..... accurate enough ( minute of bad guy) can be accurized easy enough. No it is not a 1000 metre gun, but who cares?? You would not use .223 anyways for that distance.
It may not be a great gun, or put Barret out of business, but it IS a fun gun, plus the anti's hate it, which is good enough in my books to get one.
No offence to anyone that has one and maybe yours is better than the one I had but why would you want one of those?
They are way more money than they are worth in my opinion.
I had an older one with 1:7 twist barrel and while it was very reliable it was terrible in the accuracy department. I think it was about 4 inch groups at 100 yards on a good day. I just made a lot of noise with it and had to appologise to everyone sitting to my right at the range about the brass flying 30 feet over and hitting people.
Save your money for a decent rifle. You will end up spending the money you saved trying to put an aftermarket stock on it and buying expensive mags trying to make it a black rifle and will eventually sell it and buy a real black rifle anyway.
YMMV
Mine was a 1987 production (if I remember correctly) 1:7 twist stainless ranch rifle with pin on muzzle brake and synthetic folding stock and it was the least accurate rifle I have ever owned.
My AR180b that I replaced it with would shoot at least half the size groups that the mini-14 did and looked a lot cooler without having to spend a bunch of money on a stock.
Shortest rifles? All non restricted "black" rifles have an 18.5" +/- barrel to be as short as possible and still legal so that ones a tie. And I don't consider the mini to be a black rifle, at least not until you put a fancy stock on it which is another $200 or more.
Box magazine? Sure if you want to TRY to find RUGER factory high capacity pinned mags that aren't at least double the cost of an AR mag. I had 4 5/30's and a couple factory 5 round mags and 3 out of 4 of the 5/30's were reliable but they are hard to come across and expensive if you do find them.
Accurate enough? If you are satisfied with barn door accuracy then sure.
Minute of bad guy? Hope you don't have things behind said bad guy that you don't want holes in like your family because you will probably be pulling the trigger more than once if he is more than 25 feet away.
I didn't buy it looking for a 1000m gun. I thought it was a cool looking NR semi and it took me about 100 rounds till I decided it was not going to be taking up space in my gun locker very much longer.
I expect all firearms to at least shoot 2-3 minute or they are down the road. My SKS was more accurate than my mini-14 and that was with open sights compared to a scoped mini.
I would suggest someone buy an SKS before I would think of suggesting a mini-14. Best part is that you can buy 3 SKS's and a couple fancy stocks for the cost of a mini.
Why would you want to spend that much money on a rifle and have to modify it as soon as you buy it just to get it to shoot 100yds and make a group that didn't look like a pistol was being used freehand at 50yds?
To the OP I would go with the SU-16 if you have it narrowed down to the two based on price. If you can afford it I would buy a new or used XCR then down the road you can buy a caliber conversion kit and hunt with it using 6.8SPC or shoot cheap surplus 7.62x39. Or keep your eyes open on the EE for a used AR-180b. I still regret selling that one.



























