Makasi mk15 initial overview and issues

Marstar is shipping their first pre-order batch of rifles this coming week. Total number unknown, but apparently not enough to finish pre-orders for the 12" Handguard until they receive a 2nd batch of rifles in 2 week's time. These 12" Handguard rifles are apparently the Gravel-imported guns, FWIW. images.jpg
 
I put 150ish rounds through mine for the first time yesterday before I ran out of daylight. Experienced a ton of light strikes. I didn't take apart or clean the bcg at all before I went out but I probably should have, it was a little sticky in there. Its all clean again now so I'm hoping next time will do better. I was getting a disappointing 1-2 light strikes per LAR mag.

When it was working properly it was awesome though!
 
I put 150ish rounds through mine for the first time yesterday before I ran out of daylight. Experienced a ton of light strikes. I didn't take apart or clean the bcg at all before I went out but I probably should have, it was a little sticky in there. Its all clean again now so I'm hoping next time will do better. I was getting a disappointing 1-2 light strikes per LAR mag.

When it was working properly it was awesome though!

You should start to experience reliable function within the next 50 rounds or so, as you complete the 200-round Break-In cycle.

Let us know how the next range trip goes....
 
For anyone who has one of these and expirenced light strikes initially but then they cleared up after a couple hundred rounds can you see any noticeable wear anywhere that occurred in order for the gun to break in?
Just curious as to what has to wear in in order for these to be reliable
The other offering the Carmel doesn’t appear to have any break in required for it to work properly
 
For anyone who has one of these and expirenced light strikes initially but then they cleared up after a couple hundred rounds can you see any noticeable wear anywhere that occurred in order for the gun to break in?
Just curious as to what has to wear in in order for these to be reliable
The other offering the Carmel doesn’t appear to have any break in required for it to work properly

I stand to be corrected, but I believe the Break-In period with the Makasi is mostly associated with the nested Operating Springs taking a proper long-term set. This in turn, eliminates the "bolt bounce" which results in the random, occasional light primer strikes that most Makasi owners experience during the initial 200 rounds or so.

Like I said, I stand to be corrected, but the Operating Springs seem to me to be the primary culprit when it comes to those light strikes during Makasi break-in....

While the Carmel does not require a break-in period for reliable function, it has several other drawbacks which keep me from wanting one. Heavy weight before accessories, pencil barrel, questionable accuracy, zero aftermarket support, proprietary trigger, no ability to upgrade or rebarrel, etc. Oh, and the "chunky/thick" aesthetics don't appeal to me at all.
 
Last edited:
For anyone who has one of these and expirenced light strikes initially but then they cleared up after a couple hundred rounds can you see any noticeable wear anywhere that occurred in order for the gun to break in?
Just curious as to what has to wear in in order for these to be reliable
The other offering the Carmel doesn’t appear to have any break in required for it to work properly

I have not seen any specific wear point. As best as I can tell Bartok is correct regarding the springs.
 
I put 150ish rounds through mine for the first time yesterday before I ran out of daylight. Experienced a ton of light strikes. I didn't take apart or clean the bcg at all before I went out but I probably should have, it was a little sticky in there. Its all clean again now so I'm hoping next time will do better. I was getting a disappointing 1-2 light strikes per LAR mag.

When it was working properly it was awesome though!
And those arent “light strikes” in the traditional sense. Thankfully ar bolts have oob detonation prevention otherwise both me and you would have ‘sploded by now. The primer mark is from the free float firing pin just kissing the primer when chambering the round. Pulling the trigger just results in the bolt being tapped that extra “c-hair” into battery with a crispy click.
 
And those arent “light strikes” in the traditional sense. Thankfully ar bolts have oob detonation prevention otherwise both me and you would have ‘sploded by now. The primer mark is from the free float firing pin just kissing the primer when chambering the round. Pulling the trigger just results in the bolt being tapped that extra “c-hair” into battery with a crispy click.
I had an OOB with chrypto? If I recall, I believe that used an AR BCG
Firing pin cracked in half
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2073.png
    IMG_2073.png
    529.5 KB · Views: 27
  • IMG_2074.png
    IMG_2074.png
    585.2 KB · Views: 27
And those arent “light strikes” in the traditional sense. Thankfully ar bolts have oob detonation prevention otherwise both me and you would have ‘sploded by now. The primer mark is from the free float firing pin just kissing the primer when chambering the round. Pulling the trigger just results in the bolt being tapped that extra “c-hair” into battery with a crispy click.
This is my first ar style firearm so I'm not too clued in on the whole bolt operation, but that makes sense.
These primers looked the same as the spent casings though so I was pretty confused.
 
I stand to be corrected, but I believe the Break-In period with the Makasi is mostly associated with the nested Operating Springs taking a proper long-term set. This in turn, eliminates the "bolt bounce" which results in the random, occasional light primer strikes that most Makasi owners experience during the initial 200 rounds or so.

Like I said, I stand to be corrected, but the Operating Springs seem to me to be the primary culprit when it comes to those light strikes during Makasi break-in....

While the Carmel does not require a break-in period for reliable function, it has several other drawbacks which keep me from wanting one. Heavy weight before accessories, pencil barrel, questionable accuracy, zero aftermarket support, proprietary trigger, no ability to upgrade or rebarrel, etc. Oh, and the "chunky/thick" aesthetics don't appeal to me at all.
One fellow on Reddit contacted Brigade Mfg. about his intial break-in problems and the manufacturer mentioned that they delivered rifles with BCG's that were known to have tolerance issues. [https://www.reddit.com/r/canadaguns/s/mSfoR33hJb] It's definitely not the only possibility, but the use of lapping compound is now a seemingly effective remedy to accelerate the break-in process.

FWIW, many new Carmel owners are reporting generally 2-3 MOA accuracy with cheap bulk ammunition. It's been said many times before - the Carmel is a solid out-of-the-box option while the Makasi will appeal to those who want to upgrade their rifle's performance.
 
Iron Brotherhood on Instagram said they very heavily lubed their Makasi during their first few hundred rounds and did not have light primer strikes. Not sure if it will work for everyone, but maybe worth a try if you are getting a lot of light primer strikes?
 
Ive recleaned and lubed the bcg and just racked the charging handle a few hundred times and it seems to lock in much easier now. Not sure when Ill be able to get to the range next but im hoping that helps the issue a little.
 
Marstar is shipping their first pre-order batch of rifles this coming week. Total number unknown, but apparently not enough to finish pre-orders for the 12" Handguard until they receive a 2nd batch of rifles in 2 week's time. These 12" Handguard rifles are apparently the Gravel-imported guns, FWIW. View attachment 1240169
Looking like dealers are getting them now, Crafm just posted this
1794927607720.png
 
I'd be more worried if Brigade was delivering too many rifles and letting QC slip to meet the demand.

If everyone just experiences light primer strikes for a break-in period that's tolerable given the lack of options for modern semis.
 
Back
Top Bottom