Need info on S&W 586 vs 686

RHall said:
Depending on what your using it for be sure to check the sights out on them, you can get them with the adjustable rear sight and 4 position adjustable front sight I believe there called (Whichita sights).

Hello
They Only had this sight set up for a very short time on the Model 586's I Believe it was a four year run of them. It remained on the model 29's for a much Longer Period. They called them Target Champion sights and here is a model 586-1 that was Only a One Year offering. Hammerdown.



PICT0022.jpg

PICT0027a.jpg
 
bobpel said:
Thanks for the answer. Can you tell more about what is Power Port?

bobpel if you look at the picture in Hammerdown's post of the 586-1 it looks like it is power ported. It is ported right at the front sight. Some of the revolvers that S&W offers are ported at the factory but I have seen it done after market. A buddy of mine has a Model 29 that he had ported.
 
Bullwinkle said:
bobpel if you look at the picture in Hammerdown's post of the 586-1 it looks like it is power ported. It is ported right at the front sight. Some of the revolvers that S&W offers are ported at the factory but I have seen it done after market. A buddy of mine has a Model 29 that he had ported.

Hello Bullwinkle
That is not a Power Port, it is the Sight adjustment wheel to raise and Lower the front sight for different Range shooting distances.. It is Numbered One Through Five..Hammerdown
 
Sorry, when I first looked at it I thought it was power ported but now that you pointed the wheel out I can see it. I can honestly say that I have never seen that before and it sure does look interesting. Did it come from the factory like that or is it an add on?
 
Bullwinkle said:
Sorry, when I first looked at it I thought it was power ported but now that you pointed the wheel out I can see it. I can honestly say that I have never seen that before and it sure does look interesting. Did it come from the factory like that or is it an add on?


Hi
They were a Factory Option. They called this revolver the Target Champion. It was designed to allow the Sillouette shooter the Option of shooting 25-50-75-100-200 Yards by simply changing the thumb wheel setting , and by doing this it Put the revolver dead on target at the Graduated distances as long as the correct Bullet weight was selected.It is set on Four small Coil springs and by changing the thumb wheel it raises or Lowers the complete front sight. It was Only on the Model 586 as an Option for about Three to Four Years and dropped. It stayed an Option on the Massive-N-frame model 29 which is a .44 Magnum for a Lot Longer Period of time.. Hammerdown
 
Hammerdown said:
Hi
They were a Factory Option. They called this revolver the Target Champion. It was designed to allow the Sillouette shooter the Option of shooting 25-50-75-100-200 Yards by simply changing the thumb wheel setting , and by doing this it Put the revolver dead on target at the Graduated distances as long as the correct Bullet weight was selected.It is set on Four small Coil springs and by changing the thumb wheel it raises or Lowers the complete front sight. It was Only on the Model 586 as an Option for about Three to Four Years and dropped. It stayed an Option on the Massive-N-frame model 29 which is a .44 Magnum for a Lot Longer Period of time.. Hammerdown

Wrong!

It was a standard model that was made for PPC and the 686 had that barrel available also.
 
RePete said:
Wrong!

It was a standard model that was made for PPC and the 686 had that barrel available also.
WRONG !!
I don't know where you got your Information, But mine is Based on Owning the one shown since new, and by Contacting My Roy Jinks for additional Information on this Target Champion Model. The 586 was offered in 1991 on a Model 586 Dash 1 and in 1987 the Dash One changed to a Dash Two series and these were NEVER a Standard offering, they were Called Target Champion. As I stated there were very few of these and they command a Premium according to my Refrence books, and Mr. Jinks. They were Originally designed for I.P.C. Shooters. mainly Police Departments as S&W was attempting to Stimulate more Intrest back in revolver's as the Semi Auto's had hit the scene and Revolver's were slow moving at that time period. Mine has It's original Box marked Product Code 103494. It was a special order revolver made in small quantities. The 686's did not have this sight until 1992 and Like the 586's they were made in small quantities and command a Premium. The Product code for this Target Champion Option was 104268. The Specific PPC Revolver was a Model 686 PPC Revolver, they had a custom Underlug, Integral Barrel Port, and they came from the Performance Center. No Mention of the Optional Target Champion front sight available on this PPC Revolver. Roy Jinks said Mine shipped in March 1986 as well. Hammerdown
 
The 686 w/adjustable front sight looked exactly like a standard 686 w/ramp sight. A standard model with the full underlug. No different barrel weights. and the standard practice was to install a Jarvis underlug weight.

Where am I getting my info? I lived through it.

I have a friend who, in 1989, bought an adjustable front sight model - no special order and not Performance Center. He decided that he didn't like the front sight because the adjustments, along with the standard adjustable rear sight wasn't good enough, so he got a Power Custom rib sight and went to have that installed but no go. Where the front sight was installed the slot didn't allow the drilling and tapping of 1 screw hole (no meat), so he had to get the barrel changed.

There weren't any porting as porting isn't (wasn't) allowed in PPC.

The Performance Center opened in '89 or '90.
 
RePete said:
The 686 w/adjustable front sight looked exactly like a standard 686 w/ramp sight. A standard model with the full underlug. No different barrel weights. and the standard practice was to install a Jarvis underlug weight.

Where am I getting my info? I lived through it.

I have a friend who, in 1989, bought an adjustable front sight model - no special order and not Performance Center. He decided that he didn't like the front sight because the adjustments, along with the standard adjustable rear sight wasn't good enough, so he got a Power Custom rib sight and went to have that installed but no go. Where the front sight was installed the slot didn't allow the drilling and tapping of 1 screw hole (no meat), so he had to get the barrel changed.

There weren't any porting as porting isn't (wasn't) allowed in PPC.

The Performance Center opened in '89 or '90.



Hello
I see Your Friend had the revolver, so that makes you an Expert on this gun ? :confused: I don't know about the model 686's barrels Looking the same, as I do Not Own a Model 686 to Look at, but if you are speaking of the Model 586 Barrels being the same in a standard Model compared to the Target Champion Model You are WRONG again saying it was the exact same style Barrel as other model 586's. ;) Truth of the matter is, The Optional Target Champion Model I have, and which is shown has a Much Higher Rib on top of the barrel compared to a standard model 586, to allow enogh depth for this special target adjustable front sight to set flush on the ramp of which I also have an Early 1980's 4" Model in Nickel shown. If your friend had his original box it would show on the Product Code SKU on the box end Flap, to be different than the standard model 586's back then. It was offered through a dash Three series up around 1993 or so, then Dropped and Not offered again on the Model 586 Well, I have the one shown and Bought mine new, and clearly remember the Optional sight being offered as an add on accessory Option to the standard model 586 and it Tacked on another $65.00 above the standard model 586 Retail Price. The sight was an Option and it was an Upgrade Option for READ THIS CLOSE, since you Obviously didn't in your last response, Intended for "I.P.C" Shooter's, Not P.P.C. Shooters.;) This sight set up was NOT offered, nor never was ever for P.P.C. Shooters as I said, They had a P.P.C. Shooters Model in the "686" stainless Version and it WAS A Custom, Shop offering back in the Mid 1990's, and Yes, This Model was Inteneded for P.P.C. Style shoots, Not I.P.C. . :rolleyes: The Performance Center opened it's doors in the spring of 1990 Not 1989. All custom Built guns Prior to this were done off the Companies standard assembly lines and based on customer requests. Back in 1965 Dayton Outdoor Sports a Large Police supply S&W Stocking Dealer in Dayton, Ohio Placed such an order for a special Built Model 14 revolver. This revolver was Known as the "Dayton Revolver". S&W reserved a special 4 Block serial range for this revolver that started Production in 1965 and continued until 1968 which by that Time filled the complete order of 2038 special built Dayton Revolvers. Here is one of those Models, which I have had for a Couple of Years in original form that shipped in June of 1966. They differed from the standard Model 14 Target masterpiece models as they had a Baughman quick draw front sight, a Bull style Heavy barrel, and 4" Barrel lengths Normally only seen on the Model 15 Combat Masterpieces. They were Offered in Nickel or Blued and fewer were made in Nickel than Blued. You could have gotten an assortment of available Triggers and Hammers, Mine are the narrow Target versions and Grips also could be had either in the service diamond style or the Larger Diamond Targets like shown. I have had this revolver Lettered and it came back as an Original Dayton Revolver Built Many Years before S&W even though about Having a Performance center. I do shoot this revolver occasionally in IPC Events alonf with my target Champion model 586 shown above. Regards, Hammerdown



e09b3138.jpg





DaytonRevolverAdd.jpg

DSCF6259.jpg

DSCF6897.jpg
 
Last edited:
Hammerdown said:
Hello
I see Your Friend had the revolver, so that makes you an Expert on this gun ? :confused: I don't know about the model 686's barrels Looking the same, as I do Not Own a Model 686 to Look at, but if you are speaking of the Model 586 Barrels being the same in a standard Model compared to the Target Champion Model You are WRONG again saying it was the exact same style Barrel as other model 586's. ;) Truth of the matter is, The Optional Target Champion Model I have, and which is shown has a Much Higher Rib on top of the barrel compared to a standard model 586, to allow enogh depth for this special target adjustable front sight to set flush on the ramp of which I also have an Early 1980's 4" Model in Nickel shown. If your friend had his original box it would show on the Product Code SKU on the box end Flap, to be different than the standard model 586's back then. It was offered through a dash Three series up around 1993 or so, then Dropped and Not offered again on the Model 586 Well, I have the one shown and Bought mine new, and clearly remember the Optional sight being offered as an add on accessory Option to the standard model 586 and it Tacked on another $65.00 above the standard model 586 Retail Price. The sight was an Option and it was an Upgrade Option for READ THIS CLOSE, since you Obviously didn't in your last response, Intended for "I.P.C" Shooter's, Not P.P.C. Shooters.;) This sight set up was NOT offered, nor never was ever for P.P.C. Shooters as I said, They had a P.P.C. Shooters Model in the "686" stainless Version and it WAS A Custom, Shop offering back in the Mid 1990's, and Yes, This Model was Inteneded for P.P.C. Style shoots, Not I.P.C. . :rolleyes: The Performance Center opened it's doors in the spring of 1990 Not 1989. All custom Built guns Prior to this were done off the Companies standard assembly lines and based on customer requests. Back in 1965 Dayton Outdoor Sports a Large Police supply S&W Stocking Dealer in Dayton, Ohio Placed such an order for a special Built Model 14 revolver. This revolver was Known as the "Dayton Revolver". S&W reserved a special 4 Block serial range for this revolver that started Production in 1965 and continued until 1968 which by that Time filled the complete order of 2038 special built Dayton Revolvers. Here is one of those Models, which I have had for a Couple of Years in original form that shipped in June of 1966. They differed from the standard Model 14 Target masterpiece models as they had a Baughman quick draw front sight, a Bull style Heavy barrel, and 4" Barrel lengths Normally only seen on the Model 15 Combat Masterpieces. They were Offered in Nickel or Blued and fewer were made in Nickel than Blued. You could have gotten an assortment of available Triggers and Hammers, Mine are the narrow Target versions and Grips also could be had either in the service diamond style or the Larger Diamond Targets like shown. I have had this revolver Lettered and it came back as an Original Dayton Revolver Built Many Years before S&W even though about Having a Performance center. I do shoot this revolver occasionally in IPC Events alonf with my target Champion model 586 shown above. Regards, Hammerdown

First of, I NEVER said I was an expert, just a certified S&W factory armourer for pistol and revolver. What are your qualifications?

Secondly I said 686 and not 586, as you keep refering to.

I was going to buy a 686 w/adjustable front sight until my friend stated the sights were too fine for shooting fast.

Check the year I said he bought his. You're NOT reading my post.

I did read close and the version I'm talking about was for PPC.

As for the last part of your post, it's totally irrelivant to the topic at hand.
 
RePete said:
[QUOTE

First of, I NEVER said I was an expert, just a certified S&W factory armourer for pistol and revolver. What are your qualifications?

Secondly I said 686 and not 586, as you keep refering to.

I was going to buy a 686 w/adjustable front sight until my friend stated the sights were too fine for shooting fast.

Check the year I said he bought his. You're NOT reading my post.

I did read close and the version I'm talking about was for PPC.

As for the last part of your post, it's totally irrelivant to the topic at hand.


Hello
Anybody can attend the Smith & Wesson Armorer School, that is a Public course offered to all. {SEE THE LINK} What have you got in revolver's, So far all I see is what your friend had, and what you were GOING to Buy, But eveidently didn't ? /B] Wind is cheap it Take $$$$ To build a collection. I have been collecting over 25 Years and currently have more than I care to count any more, and have done action jobs on most of them, without going to Armourer School. I am a certified NRA Range safety officer, Belong to The NRA and have been in the Smith & Wesson Collectors association for a while, and this is where I base my information from, a factual Internet forum for S&WCA Members only. Mr Roy Jinks is the master at answering any questions I may have, and second Opinions are not worth Face Value to me over his. He is the one I asked about these model 586 Target Champions Long before this thread came out or transpired, and he was the One that told me all I need to know abut S&Ws, or answers accuratly and Precise any questions I may have about S&W's. The revolver shown is an example of what one could get Long before the Performance shop even hit the scene, and is a rare specimin, and I though maybe Other's may enjoy seeing a rare revolver, I can Guarantee you are not the reason I showed this. As I said, Where are your collectible revolvers ? By the amount of Post count you have here it appears you have more wind than hardeware. I am done with this thread, and it is sad, One can't show examples without being Badgered with Back wash.., and I waill say it again..Let's see yours ? :bsFlag: Hammerdown

http://www.smith-wesson.com/webapp/...goryDisplay?catalogId=12601&storeId=10001&cat
 
Last edited:
Hammerdown said:
RePete said:
Hello
Anybody can attend the Smith & Wesson Armorer School, that is a Public course offered to all. {SEE THE LINK} What have you got in revolver's, So far all I see is what your friend had, and what you were GOING to Buy, But eveidently didn't ? /B] Wind is cheap it Take $$$$ To build a collection. I have been collecting over 25 Years and currently have more than I care to count any more, and have done action jobs on most of them, without going to Armourer School. I am a certified NRA Range safety officer, Belong to The NRA and have been in the Smith & Wesson Collectors association for a while, and this is where I base my information from, a factual Internet forum for S&WCA Members only. Mr Roy Jinks is the master at answering any questions I may have, and second Opinions are not worth Face Value to me over his. He is the one I asked about these model 586 Target Champions Long before this thread came out or transpired, and he was the One that told me all I need to know abut S&Ws, or answers accuratly and Precise any questions I may have about S&W's. The revolver shown is an example of what one could get Long before the Performance shop even hit the scene, and is a rare specimin, and I though maybe Other's may enjoy seeing a rare revolver, I can Guarantee you are not the reason I showed this. As I said, Where are your collectible revolvers ? By the amount of Post count you have here it appears you have more wind than hardeware. I am done with this thread, and it is sad, One can't show examples without being Badgered with Back wash.., and I waill say it again..Let's see yours ? :bsFlag: Hammerdown

http://www.smith-wesson.com/webapp/...goryDisplay?catalogId=12601&storeId=10001&cat


The link has a general error.

I attended the LEO courses that aren't available to civvies.

My revolvers (all L-Frames) with a 625 in 45 ACP that's not in the picture. And that's only the revolvers, there are a few others.

RevRosette.jpg


What was I going to buy but didn't? A 686 w/adjustable front sight.

Certified factory police armourer for Beretta, S&W (pistol and revolver), SIG, Rem 870. Owner of my own Police Armourer Service.

Member of NROI, NRA, NFA, CSSA,IPSC, IDPA, PPC instructor, IDPA instuctor, senior RSO for a Military Base gun club.

I don't own collectables because I shyoot everyone on my guns. I don't have a problem with people collecting. Each to his own.

Now get your head out of your A$$.
 
RePete said:
No, you will need to replace the barrel, unless you can get someone to made an insert with a ramp and sight on it.


Could this barrel have an Witchata or Aristocrat sight installed? Or do the holes from the front sight get in the way, or the cutout from the front sight cause a problem ??
 
Hammerdown said:
Hi
They were a Factory Option. They called this revolver the Target Champion. It was designed to allow the Sillouette shooter the Option of shooting 25-50-75-100-200 Yards by simply changing the thumb wheel setting , and by doing this it Put the revolver dead on target at the Graduated distances as long as the correct Bullet weight was selected.It is set on Four small Coil springs and by changing the thumb wheel it raises or Lowers the complete front sight. It was Only on the Model 586 as an Option for about Three to Four Years and dropped. It stayed an Option on the Massive-N-frame model 29 which is a .44 Magnum for a Lot Longer Period of time.. Hammerdown

I picked up a 586-1 made in 89' with this adjustable sight, so I'm glad to get some background information on it. So the thumbwheel allows you to select one of 4 settings. I was told that for any given setting, say setting 1, you are able to do some finer adjustments by turning the small screw at the top of the sight with a small hex screw. If I rotate the adjustment screw clockwise, does that raise or lower the sight?

Back to the original question of this thread, I really enjoy shooting the 586 6". I was going to get the 686, but I think the blued is more of a collectors item, and was less expensive. In the end, both are great.

Derek
 
The sights were a PITA to adjust.

Once they were adjusted (for PPC - 7yds and 15yds center hold, 25yds center hold, 25yds neck hold and 50yds neck hold) all you had to do was rotate the wheel to the number you selected for that range.
 
Back
Top Bottom