Need Suggestions: Unrestricted Semi-Auto 223

Grendeb

Regular
Rating - 100%
4   0   1
Location
Quebec
Good day to all,

I am looking for an unrestricted semi auto rifle in 223 preferably to be an alternative for my 308 bolt gun, lighter weight (gun and ammo) compact for hicking in the snow and coyote hunting.

My eyes got caught on the Ketec SU16 (all the nay say please stay on topic of suggesting an alternative)
My only concern is that the version I have my eyes on cost 1000-1200$ and I know what accuracy I could expect from this which would be 1-2 MOA, for coyote hunting up to 300yards that'll make the job probably hard so are there any other alternatives?

Semi auto, compact, reasonably light weight, precise, maybe higher quality in the price range of 1500$ new/used that I'm unaware?
I know a company making unrestricted AR Style gun but I have many other things to buy before a 4000$ gun.
 
Look for a used ruger mini rifle as an entry level gun. Reasonable price,lots of accessories around. Think about
Wolfe guns springs set to make them work better.
 
Not a lot of options in your price range really. The keltec comes to mind, so does a 223cal vz58 or a mini14.

None of these are known to be particularly accurate though, especially if you want to hit coyotes at 300yds.

I'm in the same boat, i want a 223 semi NR, but the options available at the price I can afford kinda suck. I've almost gotten a keltrc su16 a few times, you can get the base model for under $800 and upgrade the stock later... but Im hesitant due to mixed reviews on accuracy.

I ended up with a 243 bolt gun for putting holes in dogs. Cheaper and more useful to me than a 223 with mediocre accuracy.
 
You won't find what you're looking for at that price point.
The SU-16 is in the price range but it is not a 1-2moa rifle. I've shot 2 of them and neither one was very impressive in the accuracy department. Both functioned 100% reliably though. As Suther said, you can upgrade stuff on them but I wouldn't bother as those upgrades cost and you'll end up being over your budget and still have a rifle that doesn't shoot all that well.
A Norinco T97 is another in your price range and I've heard of a few people getting decent groups, still not 1 moa but better than an SU-16. Problem with Norinco is there are no parts and no warranty, both of which are kinda important on a rifle made in China with little to no quality control. One guy gets a rifle that functions fine and the next could be a paperweight.
A Ruger mini 14 is in your price range and the target model is supposed to shoot better than the barn door accuracy of the older ranch rifles but the target model is pretty heavy and uses silly Ruger magazines that are more expensive and harder to find than an AR magazine.
I would say for under $2000 the best option is an AR180B-2 but since they are discontinued they are hard to find and even harder to get parts for if needed. They are not a 1moa rifle, prob not a 2 moa rifle but they shoot well enough for a coyote in my opinion and they are very light.
If you can move your budget up to $2000ish I would watch the EE for a while and keep your eyes open for a good deal on an XCR-L, I saw a new keymod version sell for well under $2000 last week but those are super rare deals and I think that one lasted an hour before it sold.

What you're asking for is pretty much unobtainable for the price range you want. To get a non restricted rifle that is truely capable of moa you need to look at an HK SL8 and those are typically around $2000 used and upgrades are expensive. Other than that a Bushmaster ACR that has been converted to NR is the next one in line if you want close to 1 moa.
Both of those rifles fail in your light weight requirement as both are around 8-9 pounds without a scope.

Keep in mind as well that if you're on a tight budget and buying a rifle that's $1500-$2000 is going to stretch your finances then you probably won't be able to feed it quality ammo that will produce the groups your looking for.
As was mentioned earlier a quality bolt action can be purchased for under $1000 then add a $500-$1000 optic and you've got one heck of a coyote rig that is not only more accurate than any semi you can afford it is also lighter.

I'm sorry if this is discouraging but unless you up your budget you won't be happy with what you get then you'll spend a bunch of money "upgrading" it but those upgrades turn out to only make it look better but it still shoots 2-4 moa on a good day. Then you'll sell it for a loss and buy the more expensive rifle that you should have bought the first time. Most of us have done it and seen it over and over, for a good non restricted semi you have to pay to play.
 
You won't find what you're looking for at that price point.
The SU-16 is in the price range but it is not a 1-2moa rifle. I've shot 2 of them and neither one was very impressive in the accuracy department. Both functioned 100% reliably though. As Suther said, you can upgrade stuff on them but I wouldn't bother as those upgrades cost and you'll end up being over your budget and still have a rifle that doesn't shoot all that well.
A Norinco T97 is another in your price range and I've heard of a few people getting decent groups, still not 1 moa but better than an SU-16. Problem with Norinco is there are no parts and no warranty, both of which are kinda important on a rifle made in China with little to no quality control. One guy gets a rifle that functions fine and the next could be a paperweight.
A Ruger mini 14 is in your price range and the target model is supposed to shoot better than the barn door accuracy of the older ranch rifles but the target model is pretty heavy and uses silly Ruger magazines that are more expensive and harder to find than an AR magazine.
I would say for under $2000 the best option is an AR180B-2 but since they are discontinued they are hard to find and even harder to get parts for if needed. They are not a 1moa rifle, prob not a 2 moa rifle but they shoot well enough for a coyote in my opinion and they are very light.
If you can move your budget up to $2000ish I would watch the EE for a while and keep your eyes open for a good deal on an XCR-L, I saw a new keymod version sell for well under $2000 last week but those are super rare deals and I think that one lasted an hour before it sold.

What you're asking for is pretty much unobtainable for the price range you want. To get a non restricted rifle that is truely capable of moa you need to look at an HK SL8 and those are typically around $2000 used and upgrades are expensive. Other than that a Bushmaster ACR that has been converted to NR is the next one in line if you want close to 1 moa.
Both of those rifles fail in your light weight requirement as both are around 8-9 pounds without a scope.

Keep in mind as well that if you're on a tight budget and buying a rifle that's $1500-$2000 is going to stretch your finances then you probably won't be able to feed it quality ammo that will produce the groups your looking for.
As was mentioned earlier a quality bolt action can be purchased for under $1000 then add a $500-$1000 optic and you've got one heck of a coyote rig that is not only more accurate than any semi you can afford it is also lighter.

I'm sorry if this is discouraging but unless you up your budget you won't be happy with what you get then you'll spend a bunch of money "upgrading" it but those upgrades turn out to only make it look better but it still shoots 2-4 moa on a good day. Then you'll sell it for a loss and buy the more expensive rifle that you should have bought the first time. Most of us have done it and seen it over and over, for a good non restricted semi you have to pay to play.

Sound advice right here. If you cant afford it, save until you can. Buy once/cry once and watch like a hawk for good deals.
 
Mini 14

PAR is not semi but fantastic. Also over max of price range.

Benelli mr1


The mr1 is a very nice rifle.

The PAR would be my pick though.
 
I echo the comments on the SU16. Not very accurate, and they just feel very plasticky.

I've been very happy with my Tavor, though it's heavy. Mine regularly runs about 2MOA, which is fine by me.

You can pick good Tavor deals ($2000-2200) off the EE now as a lot of guys seem to be dumping them in prep for the X95.
 
You won't find what you're looking for at that price point.
The SU-16 is in the price range but it is not a 1-2moa rifle. I've shot 2 of them and neither one was very impressive in the accuracy department. Both functioned 100% reliably though. As Suther said, you can upgrade stuff on them but I wouldn't bother as those upgrades cost and you'll end up being over your budget and still have a rifle that doesn't shoot all that well.
A Norinco T97 is another in your price range and I've heard of a few people getting decent groups, still not 1 moa but better than an SU-16. Problem with Norinco is there are no parts and no warranty, both of which are kinda important on a rifle made in China with little to no quality control. One guy gets a rifle that functions fine and the next could be a paperweight.
A Ruger mini 14 is in your price range and the target model is supposed to shoot better than the barn door accuracy of the older ranch rifles but the target model is pretty heavy and uses silly Ruger magazines that are more expensive and harder to find than an AR magazine.
I would say for under $2000 the best option is an AR180B-2 but since they are discontinued they are hard to find and even harder to get parts for if needed. They are not a 1moa rifle, prob not a 2 moa rifle but they shoot well enough for a coyote in my opinion and they are very light.
If you can move your budget up to $2000ish I would watch the EE for a while and keep your eyes open for a good deal on an XCR-L, I saw a new keymod version sell for well under $2000 last week but those are super rare deals and I think that one lasted an hour before it sold.

What you're asking for is pretty much unobtainable for the price range you want. To get a non restricted rifle that is truely capable of moa you need to look at an HK SL8 and those are typically around $2000 used and upgrades are expensive. Other than that a Bushmaster ACR that has been converted to NR is the next one in line if you want close to 1 moa.
Both of those rifles fail in your light weight requirement as both are around 8-9 pounds without a scope.

Keep in mind as well that if you're on a tight budget and buying a rifle that's $1500-$2000 is going to stretch your finances then you probably won't be able to feed it quality ammo that will produce the groups your looking for.
As was mentioned earlier a quality bolt action can be purchased for under $1000 then add a $500-$1000 optic and you've got one heck of a coyote rig that is not only more accurate than any semi you can afford it is also lighter.

I'm sorry if this is discouraging but unless you up your budget you won't be happy with what you get then you'll spend a bunch of money "upgrading" it but those upgrades turn out to only make it look better but it still shoots 2-4 moa on a good day. Then you'll sell it for a loss and buy the more expensive rifle that you should have bought the first time. Most of us have done it and seen it over and over, for a good non restricted semi you have to pay to play.

Thanks for the info mate.
Believe me I understand and follow the concept of paying more instead of cheap and adding stuff afterwards.
That's the main idea of my topic if there's a gun meeting all my requirements for a little bit more money I'm all for it but my priorities at this time aren't for a 3000$ gun.
I do own a Savage 10FCP-SR in 308 for longer shots (300 yards) if needed.
Of course my reference is in the USA they have a lot of different guns meeting these requirements for the price point and even bellow, still I'm surprize and all you guys seems to agree that there's no manufacturer meeting what I need.
 
Sound advice right here. If you cant afford it, save until you can. Buy once/cry once and watch like a hawk for good deals.

Totally agree still surprized there aren't any other choice like in the states and still Keltec offers something close.

*Off topic: The only rifle I would be willing to pay more than 2000$ would be for an fnar which as of now isn't much needed since I have a 308 bolt.
 
Thanks for the info mate.
Believe me I understand and follow the concept of paying more instead of cheap and adding stuff afterwards.
That's the main idea of my topic if there's a gun meeting all my requirements for a little bit more money I'm all for it but my priorities at this time aren't for a 3000$ gun.
I do own a Savage 10FCP-SR in 308 for longer shots (300 yards) if needed.
Of course my reference is in the USA they have a lot of different guns meeting these requirements for the price point and even bellow, still I'm surprize and all you guys seems to agree that there's no manufacturer meeting what I need.

Most of what is available down south is either an AR or AK variant, the first being restricted, second prohib here. That is why you don't see as many cheap 223, there isn't really a market down there when an AR does the job and does it well. Add the aftermarket support and its a no brainer for them.
 
Benelli MR1, they sell new for around $1800 so you could probably grab a used one for $1500 or less. They take AR-15 mags and are plenty accurate enough
 
Thanks for the info mate.
Believe me I understand and follow the concept of paying more instead of cheap and adding stuff afterwards.
That's the main idea of my topic if there's a gun meeting all my requirements for a little bit more money I'm all for it but my priorities at this time aren't for a 3000$ gun.
I do own a Savage 10FCP-SR in 308 for longer shots (300 yards) if needed.
Of course my reference is in the USA they have a lot of different guns meeting these requirements for the price point and even bellow, still I'm surprize and all you guys seems to agree that there's no manufacturer meeting what I need.

If we were in the US you could just go buy a decent AR for under $1500 that would meet all your requirements but unfortunately our Canadian law makers are idiots and between them and the RCMP lab they think that the way a rifle looks determines how dangerous it is. An AR is no easier to convert to full auto than any other semi auto out there and since the parts needed to make an AR auto won't even fit into an AR-15's receiver it really makes absolutely no sense at all. That's another discussion though.
Our weak Canadian dollar isn't helping us either.
The guys in the US don't have many other options than that though, we can get most of the stuff they can and as long as it's available with an 18.6"+ barrel we can probably have it NR. The problem is that the other options are expensive and it's very uncommon for a semi automatic based on a modern military design to shoot close to 1 moa, the rifles are typically designed for a battlefield so sub 4 moa is just fine, it's our unrealistic expectations that make us think 1 moa is the benchmark for these rifles. Sometimes someone gets lucky and finds a load that works well with their barrel and they pull off a fluke group but more often than not I think guys are full of it. Most groups seen are some random target with holes all over with the five closest ones circled or could have been at 50 yards rather than 100. There is no way to verify. If you want proof have a look at the my rifle shoots 1 moa all day thread and see how many people actually have a fresh target with five groups of five with no flyers. It's really rare, even the guys spending $5000 for a decked out Modern Hunter or Modern Varmint with the expensive match grade barrel and trigger are not printing 1 moa all day. It's very hard to do with a bolt gun and a semi is even harder to do it with.

If you want a semi that will hit coyotes at 300yds I would save a little longer and buy a used Tavor or XCR-L for around $2000. Neither one is a consistent 2moa shooter (I don't care what one person got one time when the planets aligned) but both will be reliable and are accurate enough for what you want to do. Nothing you can do about the weight other than lift some weights and put a little muscle on those arms so you notice the weight of the rifle less.
If weight is a concern for carry then you're out of luck but if it's just for the weight shooting offhand then have a look at the Tavor, I used to own one and it was a well built rifle, being a bullpup helps make it feel lighter than it is. I sold it because it just didn't do it for me, I enjoy shooting my ACR, and AR180 more.
I just did a trade for another HK SL8, this is the third time I've owned one, the first two were capable of 1 moa with match grade ammo or with well developed handloads. I'm waiting for it to arrive (should be here today or tomorrow). They are heavy but they're definitely the most accurate semi auto we can buy off the shelf for under $3000.
 
Last edited:
I completely agree with him.

Option 1: Keep saving up.
Option 2: Go with a bolt gun.

What's wrong with the benelli MR1? My good buddy has one and it's every bit as accurate and reliable as an AR-15. Can shoot gophers from nearly 100Y away first shot with decent optics mounted on her.
 
I guess I'll just go with my first guess with a Keltec and see how comfortable I am shooting it.
I've seen on KT forum accuracy of 2 inches to 100yards I guess at 200yards I'd still be able to hit a coyote's head.

I have spots where I can shoot up to 800 yards and other limited to 300yards so that was the main reason into having a relatively accurate semi for those shorter ranges.
 
Back
Top Bottom