Well like I said the new BCG fixed the problem. Had to spend a little more than I was planning. It is still weird to me that the Norc bolt worked in my Colt and the bolt out of the Colt worked in the Norc. If it isn't a Norinco BCG I find that a bit odd too. Why would someone switch out made in China parts for North American ones? I will check the extractor position on the original bolt tomorrow ad make sure it isn't assembled wrong.
My only complaint now is the play between the upper and lower and I ordered an accuwedge for that.