One Caliber fits all?

What caliber do you suggest?

  • .270

    Votes: 36 15.2%
  • .300 WSM

    Votes: 16 6.8%
  • .30-06

    Votes: 157 66.2%
  • .300 Ultra Mag

    Votes: 6 2.5%
  • 12 GA Shot Gun

    Votes: 22 9.3%

  • Total voters
    237
  • Poll closed .
Since big game hunting in northern Ontario is a close range proposition, I would recommend the 45/70 with handloads, you can skip the scope if you like, or get used to the iron sights, maybe put a peep on it with a firesight front. You can add a scope latter with Quick detach rings like QRWs, and have more options for Moose, deer and bear at close to medium range.
 
While it is, quite probably, my least favorite cartridge (aside from the .303) and given your constraints - buy a 30-06.

There's not much it doesn't do well. Conversely, there's not a lot it does exceptionally well at, either.
 
I don't know about that. A 6.5x55 will kill everything from groundhogs to moose and is legal to hunt varmints with in SW Ontario.

I was waiting for someone to suggest the 6.5 Swede ^.^ sold my lee enfield Parker hale custom to get myself an M96 Mauser, was looking for a "do all" calibre myself and settled on this one, after months of research online and in shooting magazines and talking to other hunters and shooters. Now just have to wait until the mess up with Canada Post is rectified to get my new (to me) rifle :D
 
I am not a proponent of choosing inexpensive rifles for use under difficult conditions, and big game hunting in Canada most often comes with weather and topography components which are hard on rifles.

As has already been mentioned Tradex is a great source for high quality used rifles, and a used quality rifle trumps the rifle designed as a poor man's hunting gun, yet the cost can be similar. It has been my experience that when Tradex describes the condition of their rifles you can take it to the bank. I haven't bought a lot of stuff from them, but the rifles I have bought have been excellent value (my Brno ZG-47 and my wife's and my nephew's Husky 1600s). Provided you don't get a rifle with a cracked tang, these rifles are shootable right out of the box, but they are also priced so that if you want some refinements, added right away or later on, that are best addressed by a gunsmith, there is room for that in even a modest budget.

Chambering wise, your best bet lies between the 6.5X55 and the .30/06. If you suffer under the caliber restrictions of Southern Ontario, the 6.5X55 might be your best choice. Regardless of which cartridge you choose, I would urge you to begin reloading as soon as possible. Moderate cartridges (all former military cartridges fall within the moderate performance level) don't need premium bullets to perform well on game, and being affordable to shoot equals more shooting equals becoming confident with your rifle more quickly. Cast bullet loads cost just pennies to shoot whose low noise and recoil combines with good accuracy makes them enjoyable to shoot. Full power ammo loaded with Remington bulk bullets provide good hunting fodder and surprisingly good accuracy.
 
novega, i see you're from brantford too. we should get together sometime for a hunt...

around here the largest caliber we can use is .270 so id stick with that if you plan on using your rifle for crows, groundhogs, fox, coyote, etc around here. it will work well for deer, bear and moose if you decide to head north and ammo is easy to find.

you say that the guys at the gun shop didnt help at all...must have been h&h? :rolleyes: those people dont have a fricken clue about anything hunting related and their prices are through the roof.


honestly, if you plan on going hunting around here a 12 gauge would be much better than a rifle. pickup an 870 express super mag rifled combo for $600 and you will have everything from squirrels to moose covered. you'd get much more use out of the shotty.
 
I can't believe I'm saying this but there should be a couple of sporterised .303's around that you can get your hands on for cheap. You should be able to swing that a decent used 12 gauge and a .22 all for under $1000.
 
Thanks for the recommendations guys:)
I'm hunting in Northern Ontario, so I won't be limited to certain calibers. I've got a pretty good idea of what I'm looking for now.
 
Cabela's has a very good price on the Mossberg 535 Slug/Smoothbore shotgun combo. ($350? $450? I know it's cheap).

I'm pretty sure that in Eastern Canada, this would cover any - ANY - game come across.

Sure, you won't be able to snipe down deer on a powerline, or make any other shot over 100 yards . . . but slugs will kill a deer, moose, or bear deader than a doornail. I took my blackie with my Winchester 1300 duck gun this spring and I'm a believer now. I still want a deer rifle to replace my SKS, but I know now that I can use a slug gun from a blind to kill whatever I want.

Shotguns, while limited in range, are just far more versatile. If I could only have one gun, for whatever reason, it would be a 12 gauge.
 
Thanks for the recommendations guys:)
I'm hunting in Northern Ontario, so I won't be limited to certain calibers. I've got a pretty good idea of what I'm looking for now.

Just something to keep in mind. If ou live in an area where there are caliber restrictions you may not be able to practice with 30cals etc. Most important thing is practice practice practice. If you plan on shooting deer in your area you will need a shotgun or muzzleloader. So if you want one gun that will allow you to shoot moose/ deer etc you might also want to consider getting a nice inline muzzleloader
 
Back
Top Bottom