Score my deer

[Longstud]

Maybe bigger this year!!

 

[IronNoggin]

Showed this pic to a couple guys that are pretty experienced in scoring deer both on the table and on the hoof (just for fun) to get their thoughts on its score. I have no idea how they guesstimate the spread from pics like that but one figured around 193 gross and the other thought 200-205 gross. I place it solidly in the 100 to 300 range.

Here's a couple more pix that might help:

While we're at it, which do you think would score better? The one above or this one?

Cheers

 

[Licensed to kill]

So, I shared the new pics and both guys adjusted there score. The one that said 193 now says high 180’s and 175 for the second Deer. The other guy revised his score from 200-205 to 185 and 165 for the second Deer. So what do they score?

 

[track]

Here's a couple more pix that might help:

While we're at it, which do you think would score better? The one above or this one?

Cheers

The first buck would gross score 188 B&C and the other buck 162.

 

[fingers284]

Track could be very close on top ones gross score but has too many deductions for even a 180 net score...also agree on bottom buck not close to 170, nice busk but points too short for BC min.

 

[IronNoggin]

The first buck would gross score 188 B&C and the other buck 162.

Wrong

 

[BigBraz15]

Here's a couple more pix that might help:

While we're at it, which do you think would score better? The one above or this one?

Cheers

I have a buck very similar to your bottom one, pics don’t always give the best show of proportions, but I would guess 160-165 gross for the second buck.

I will have to scope out the first one more.

 

[270AB]

Now I know why so many guys say the buck they shot was 180-190. This deer in the 110-120 max range.

 

[270AB]

I have a buck very similar to your bottom one, pics don’t always give the best show of proportions, but I would guess 160-165 gross for the second buck.

I will have to scope out the first one more.

Is it not the same deer? Either way neither over 125.

 

[BigBraz15]

Is it not the same deer? Either way neither over 125.

I meant Iron Nogs deer

 

[fingers284]

Wrong

So enlighten us...its hanging on the wall, not still running across a barley field...let us know what it actually is.

 

[Licensed to kill]

Wrong

So we are clear, are you expecting someone to guess the exact score down to the 1/8” from those pics?

 

[murph83]

lol..you are all wrong. I use high accurate internet measuring tools. This deer, according to my calculations, and using the highly accurate reverse horn analyzer puts these antlers at exactly 127.897 inches..exactly. Write it down, post it on yer fridge..yall folks are welcome.