Last yr we tried a bunch of different brands/situations. Some of them actually caused the deer to abandon well used trails. Some seemed to do absolutely nothing. One actually smelled like womens perfume.
The smoke sticks were "close" smelling, but not quite.(when compared to the one that worked)
One brand however, worked as advertised. I'll pm you the maker.
I will say it wasn't a brand I've ever seen on a shelf, we ordered it over the internet from the (small) maker.
We started checking them out, as the last few yrs we've been playing with calling different species in different situations. In most cases calling doesn't work either, and in some will backfire on you, but if the situation is right, it works like a charm.
Like everything else in life, I suspect I'll have it all figured out right around the time I'm too old to hunt anymore.