Have wanted one for so long, they have a new series out and would love one. Any recommendations? I have had a couple 1911's in .45acp but I love the .357mag and have followed the coonan for awhile but was never really serious.
To Coonan or not to Coonan that is the question?
- Thread starter Davie Sprocket
- Start date
I used to agree and was looking at a s&w 686 but now looking at the new coonan I would like to hear what guys have to say about them.
.357 is probably my favorite cartridge, and I have lots of revolvers to shoot it with. No Coonan though, I don't have big enough mitts to deal with an auto in a magnum anything. You can't really compare the two, but my gut feeling is go with a 686, or a nice Model 27 if you can find one. Unless of course you do have big mitts, and don't mind flinging that expensive brass about. I'm sure it would be loads of fun....but you also better be reloading!
The Coonan is a wonderful pistol.
Fun gun. If you have the itch, you know you won't be satisfied until you scratch it. True it does not feel like a 1911, but the grip is not as big as you might think. The added benefit is that you can also shoot 38 special if you have some around or you just want some low recoil options. Even with full house 357 the recoil is not that bad and mine was quite accurate and reliable.
I'll add a counterpoint. If you aren't already into 357/38 special, and like the 1911 feel, 10mm is another option. I ended up selling my Coonan and replacing it with an STI 10mm and haven't regretted the decision. Nothing against the Coonan, but at the current price point of around $2500 before tax, I don't think the quality is on par with other 1911s in that range so I'd probably look for a used one. I guess in fairness, the price of all guns has gone up.
Still, I may buy another Coonan in the future if they come out with a rumoured long slide.
I'll add a counterpoint. If you aren't already into 357/38 special, and like the 1911 feel, 10mm is another option. I ended up selling my Coonan and replacing it with an STI 10mm and haven't regretted the decision. Nothing against the Coonan, but at the current price point of around $2500 before tax, I don't think the quality is on par with other 1911s in that range so I'd probably look for a used one. I guess in fairness, the price of all guns has gone up.
Still, I may buy another Coonan in the future if they come out with a rumoured long slide.
Last edited:
- Location
- Southwestern Ontario
Should one Coonan? Ah yes, that is the question! If one can Coonan then one should surely Coonan as much as possible. After all, if one can Coonan and rightfully does subsequently Coonan, then one becomes an object of admiration for all those who either cannot or will not Coonan. It should be noted that the vast majority of those who are not Coonaning are those who cannot Coonan versus those who choose not to Coonan. The Coonan is sublime in it's build, exquisite in it's finish, and deadly in it's accuracy. So yes, Coonan all you can, for the stuff of life is the ability to Coonan and there are few pleasures afforded the human soul so penultimate as to Coonan regularly and with abandon.
Nice lol.
I am going to look in to selling some of my other guns, to free up funds. I already load .357mag so no problem there. Also the only reason I mention the 686 was the fact that most people only apply .357mag to revolvers and not autos. I have yet to put my hands on one and would like to do that before I make the final decision. If the grips don't fit my hands then it might be a moot point. I love the idea of a magnum auto, but absolutely hate the desert eagle.
Post of the year, right here.
Davie Sprocket, the best thing is for you to try it first. I bought one after handling an example at Wanstalls. I missed an opportunity to try one when they took a bunch of guns to a local indoor range. I bought mine without ever firing one. The gun felt right in my hand. I am okay with the Glock 20 grip just for comparison. Both of them fill the hand a bit. I have a 586 and have no problems shooting that.
The first time I shot the Coonan, I was really pleasantly surprised at the low felt recoil. It's snappy for sure but not punishing in any way. The felt recoil is less than the 586 of course, because the action absorbs some of it. I like it a lot and I collect the brass. It does suck to have to chase it but .357 brass stands out since there isn't anyone else's on the ground. I hate when it gets stepped on though.
I was lucky enough to get mine before the price went so high. The dollar was still reasonable when I ordered it. The wait was long and I drove Gary at Wanstalls a bit nuts when I would stalk him about it. Sadly, the manufacturers tend to make promises they can't keep. I bought a black one. I'd probably buy the standard one if I had to do it over again but I don't regret anything about the purchase decision. Good luck!
The first time I shot the Coonan, I was really pleasantly surprised at the low felt recoil. It's snappy for sure but not punishing in any way. The felt recoil is less than the 586 of course, because the action absorbs some of it. I like it a lot and I collect the brass. It does suck to have to chase it but .357 brass stands out since there isn't anyone else's on the ground. I hate when it gets stepped on though.
I was lucky enough to get mine before the price went so high. The dollar was still reasonable when I ordered it. The wait was long and I drove Gary at Wanstalls a bit nuts when I would stalk him about it. Sadly, the manufacturers tend to make promises they can't keep. I bought a black one. I'd probably buy the standard one if I had to do it over again but I don't regret anything about the purchase decision. Good luck!
My Coonan comes out a lot more frequently than my 686 or my 627 V Comp. It is a really enjoyable gun to shoot. I have the compensated version, and I don't find the recoil much different than a 1911 with 45 ACP. I do hate the two magazines that came with it however. They are terrible, and prevent the gun from operating properly.
GD
GD
I've long romanticized the notion of getting a pressured-up 1911, but my mind always lands in the same place: Delta Elite.
That said, the Coonan is one hell of a piece. If you want it, you want it. Have fun! Life is short...and then you eat a lot of bacon, which really makes it shorter.
That said, the Coonan is one hell of a piece. If you want it, you want it. Have fun! Life is short...and then you eat a lot of bacon, which really makes it shorter.
- Location
- Southwestern Ontario
