Really...................Any firearms I have sold that I have painted have not had their re-sale value affected.........maybe even enhanced a little.....
The difference between one of your paint jobs and one completed by a well-meaning dilettante armed with a can of Krylon from Canadian Tire are light years apart, as your wink acknowledges.
As for other comments...I buy my firearms to use & shoot, not look pretty and I have no problems with honest wear. I also make it a point to maintaim my firearms properly.
Some are keepers, others will eventually be offered for sale or trade as my interests change, or I see something shiny that I have to have. Unless I know I'm never, ever going to sell, I usually try and preserve as much of the inherent resale value as I can, just in case I decide to sell it a year down the road.
Human nature being what it is, you offer two firearms of the same make, model and condition...the only difference is one having been covered in spray paint and with the same asking price, which is going to sell first or fastest?
99X our of 100, the only way the painted gun is going to go before the original condition rifle is if there is a
substantial discount offered over retail...or if you're extremely lucky enough to strike that one buyer who prefers spray-painted, used guns over shiny new ones.
For the guys who prefer to paint their guns, more power to you. The only one you have to please if yourself and if painting your bangstick gives you pleasure, have at it. I've got a pretty nice Paasche air brush & Campbell-Hausfeld compressor sitting in my workshop that I've used to create my own custom M-14 stocks so I know where you're coming from.
That said, I feel for the kids who spend major coin on a high-end black rifle and then take a can of tan spray paint to it because that is what the "operators" in the "sandbox" do... and then realize six months down the road that they need to cover next semester's tuition and have to sell their $3000-$5000 rifle - only to discover that that $6 buck's worth of Krylon has turned their pride and joy into a $1500-$2500 rifle.

