Back when we could use lead shot I used a Winchester 1200 Pump in 2 3/4 for everything.
I fell off goose & duck hunting for a few years, I stuck mostly to upland birds on account of my 1200 not being able to hit that well shooting steel. I used it one year for waterfoul (2 outings), I spent alot of time chasing wounded birds..... I didn't like that so I stopped.
Last year I bought a Bakail MP-153, 3 1/2" autoloader, I used it in the fall for everything, not a hiccup..... I guess you could say it's "my go to Goose gun".
If I could justify the expense I could see myself with a Benelli, it was what I was waiting for, I was saving up $$ (in an auto loader) untill I read all the stuff I did about the bakail, I figgured I could afford $400 to 'test' the bakail...... So far no regrets!
Cheers!