I have loaded all 3 in various rifles and they all seem to work fine. In a friends 300 WSM I worked up a load using a 180 E Tip and he has used it to harvest 3 moose so far with excellent results. With it he has shot a 2.5" group at 280 yards. The moose have been shot from 80 yards to 325 yards. I load hornady GMX 165 in my '06 at 2950fps. Shot one moose at 125 yards breaking both shoulders before exiting. Have used 150 FN Barnes TSX in my 307 at 2575 for 1.5" accuracy at 100 yards harvesting a few deer with complete penetration from various angles. I don't think you can go wrong with any of them. They all work very well. Just depends on what your gun prefers and in some cases availability. Seem to be able to find more hornady products compared to the others. Hope that helps