why the 3030?

The bottom line is, I like it, it likes me, and it does the job that it is supposed to do without making me worry about the cost to use it, or if it gets a bit marked up or not.

DSC01279.jpg

I call :p bs that photo is photoshopped, there is now way that a 30-30 with all its short comings as listed by a certain member could kill such a nice fat white tail as posted.:nest:
Nice buck and Handy rifle too btw.
Rob
 
Last edited:
I call :p bs that photo is photoshopped, there is now way that a 30-30 with all its short comings as listed by a certain member could kill such a nice fat white tail as posted.:nest:
Nice buck and Handy rifle too btw.
Rob

I am sorry Rob... I struggle to see where any member said a 30-30 would not kill a deer... please point this out to me so I can understand where you come from....
 
24 pages, are we having serious fun yet. I've hunted all my life with a 444 Marlin and know that for me that rifle is the perfect Canadian moose rifle.

Due to health driven complications I needed to limit myself to deer hunting. So I bought the perfect deer rifle for me, a pre-64 94 in 32WS. My other deer rifle is a flintlock with patched balls.

An excellent hunting rifle and round is not defined by its high velocity, sectional density, ballistic coeffecient, plastic bedding, variable scope, or price tag. My Jeep TJ is a tough agile goat of a jeep. But it is a 70 year old design concept matched or bettered by many more modern vehicles. That doesn't mean only a Mercedes Benz Land Cruiser clone is a requirement or even a better choice, just a different choice to meet a different set of needs for its owner.
 
Actually Joe... The OP posted that he does not see the virtues of the 30-30 and I posted because I agree with him and don't see the virtues.... and also disagree with the virtues posted... it's a discussion forum and as such I am entitled to my opinion.... and to post it as long as it is within rules and not hijacking a thread....

Here was my initial response in this thread... I did not post until several dozen posts later.... when someone made a statement that I wished to counter... and it all went downhill from there which was, indeed, partially my fault... as my apology stated....




Note how my initial response was about the virtues of the 30-30 as I see them.... I don't think I was unreasonable in my initial response Joe....

I don't think that was the post that got things started for you. I think it might have been this one:

There is a lot of calibers in between 30-30 and retardosuperultramag..... they used to aim with spears too... bowhunters aim... by your own analogy what makes 30-30 better than them?...
 
I don't think that was the post that got things started for you. I think it might have been this one:

LOL... no... that was pretty fair too... when taken in the context that you can either own a 30-30 or a 300 win mag without other options...

The bottom line is that the offending stuff came from another thread... also 30-30 related... I had an argument with a certain member and he went below the belt and I let it get under my skin and should not have...

Again... I apologize for bringing that chit in this one... I tried for a fresh start on the subject here and it went downhill from there...
 
24 pages, are we having serious fun yet. I've hunted all my life with a 444 Marlin and know that for me that rifle is the perfect Canadian moose rifle.

Due to health driven complications I needed to limit myself to deer hunting. So I bought the perfect deer rifle for me, a pre-64 94 in 32WS. My other deer rifle is a flintlock with patched balls.

An excellent hunting rifle and round is not defined by its high velocity, sectional density, ballistic coeffecient, plastic bedding, variable scope, or price tag. My Jeep TJ is a tough agile goat of a jeep. But it is a 70 year old design concept matched or bettered by many more modern vehicles. That doesn't mean only a Mercedes Benz Land Cruiser clone is a requirement or even a better choice, just a different choice to meet a different set of needs for its owner.

If you adjusted your settings it would only be 3 pages of crap instead of 24.... :)
 
If you adjusted your settings it would only be 3 pages of crap instead of 24.... :)

Thanks for the advice. I gather from your response that you are not interested in discussing any of the ideas in the post? Fair enough they are my thoughts and not yours after all.
 
Ffs guys... Give it a rest... I have shot more than most... It wasn't a boast ... I am well aware that many have shot and continue to shoot more than me... It wasn't a boast but a response to someone who insinuated that I never shoot... As far as military service is concerned yes, I was in the military and yes, fired many rounds and yes, I served two tours... No, unfortunately I was unable to join at age 6???

As far as the original post is concerned the question was "why the 30-30?" I have given some perfectly logical answers regarding range, versatility of load as well as availability of various actions... I have also said that 30-30's are capable of their intended purpose which is short range hunting...

You can feel free to disagree with any or all of my above statements but is it really necessary to start with the bs and bravado chit? You guys come in here pushing this cartridge like god himself created it... And act like a bunch of sharks in the water at the slightest scent of blood... The "I'm older and have shot more so I know more" attitude is getting old... Really... And the bs attitude that anyone who doesn't like a 30-30 is a magnum pusher is getting old too...

I am open to learn new things... And believe it or not I know a few things too...

No one is pushing you into liking the 30-30, and the sharks in the water thing is inaccurate, also some of us are younger than you are,( i am 32)

I started accompaning my father on hunting trips as young as 4 years old, learned to make the best of what i had.

I learned from my father that the limits most put on themselves due to equipment can most times be overcome with practice and carefull planning of the shot before pulling the trigger.

The 30-30 is cheap to shoot, light, and with proper care and consideration will fill most hunters needs.

The op asked why the 30-30, most with experience with the round suggest it for those reasons.
 
I'm going to say, sometimes I believe it's more wise to bow out of some discussions while you still have your pride & your keyboard intact. Particularly when there's nothing left to say on a matter and one is just butting heads with others for no good reason.

have a good night fellas
 
.......The price was right and ammo readily available. The rifle fits my hands very well and my eye naturally and easily finds the sights when I shoulder it. The butt doesnt grab my jacket on the way up and my arms feel like they are in the right position when I am looking down the sights.

I find it as accurate as any other rifle I have hunted deer with, and it is a easy to carry on those days I spend 6 or 8 hours walking through the bush. There is no protruding knobs or scope to get hung up in the thick stuff, and if it breaks, I can get it fixed just about anywhere.

The bottom line is, I like it, it likes me, and it does the job that it is supposed to do without making me worry about the cost to use it, or if it gets a bit marked up or not.

DSC01279.jpg

That picture is worth a thousand words without a doubt!
Nice buck and a good job, a happy hunter for sure. :)
I share the same sentiments.

MM
 
Not sure what you are seeing but my buddy that snapped the pic for me shoots a Remington something or other chambered in 30-06.

The hole you see in that "little" buck is actually an exit. I shot him at about 15 yards with those slick Hornady Leverevolution in 160 grain. The shot took out a lung and his heart before exiting his shoulder where you see the spot. He dropped like a stone.
 
Just think of all the fugly gals that would of gone to the dances if just suppose
Winchester offered the Model 100 and Model 88 in the turdy-turdy chamberings. :eek:

Neenoo nunnoo nunnoo........................:p


Laugh2Laugh2Laugh2Laugh2
 
Back
Top Bottom