I smile when shooter post comments about primers all being the same - or that primer choice does not matter.
With an easy to ignite powder, like 4895, any primer will work well. Only a small powder adjustment is required when switching primers.
When you are dealing with a difficult to ignite situation, the primer chocie makes a huge difference. In fact, some primers will give very poor results.
Difficult to ignite situations include:
- A slow powder with a heavy deterrrent coating.
- A slow powder in a less than full case, makes it even more difficult.
- A slow powder in a less than full case, with a light bullet makes it even more difficult.
- A slow powder in a less than full case, with a light bullet and no crimp/little neck tension makes it even more difficult.
- Any of the above situations using a ball power. They are usually more difficult to ignite. So loading a 45 gr bullet in 223 with a partial case full of 748 can be a problem unless you give the bullet a good crimp and use a hot primer.
If you want to see the difference in primers, load them in pistol cases and fire them (just the primed case) out of a handgun in the dark. I have done this and taken pictures (no flash) to record the differences.